Skip to main content

Reports are tying the Blue Jays to Dustin May, but the numbers say they should aim higher

Toronto needs to add a more dependable starting pitcher to shore up its 2027 rotation.
ByBen Wrixon
Oct 27, 2026; St. Petersburg, Florida, USA;  Milwaukee Brewers pitcher Dustin May (21) throws a pitch against the Tampa Bay Rays during the first inning in game four of the 2026 World Series at Tropicana Field.  Mandatory Credit: Kim Klement Neitzel-Imagn Images
Oct 27, 2026; St. Petersburg, Florida, USA; Milwaukee Brewers pitcher Dustin May (21) throws a pitch against the Tampa Bay Rays during the first inning in game four of the 2026 World Series at Tropicana Field. Mandatory Credit: Kim Klement Neitzel-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The Toronto Blue Jays are reportedly interested in free agent starting pitcher Dustin May, but they should think twice about adding him to their rotation. 

May has always had the stuff. It’s why the Milwaukee Brewers acquired him at the trade deadline, and why he made starts for them during their World Series run. The problem is that stuff doesn’t always equal results—or guarantee good health.

May recorded a 4.70 ERA and 1.318 WHIP across 31 starts in 2026 split between the Brewers and St. Louis Cardinals. 

He was actually much worse after getting traded to Milwaukee—a rare feat considering their reputation as a pitching lab. His FIP jumped from 3.16 to 5.06, and he gave up seven home runs in his 36.2 regular-season innings with the Brewers. He wasn’t sharp in the postseason either, allowing seven earned runs across his 11.2 innings pitched. 

These poor results aren’t new for May. He put up a 4.96 ERA in 2025 with the Los Angeles Dodgers and Boston Red Sox, further proving that he is a back-end starter at best. 

The truth is that May simply hasn’t been great since returning from Tommy John surgery and the esophageal tear suffered eating a salad in 2024. The promise he flashed earlier in his career with the Dodgers hasn’t materialized into consistent results in MLB. 

Dustin May's mechanics and profile are intriguing but he hasn't had recent success to back it up

So why would the Blue Jays even be interested? It probably starts with his fastball sitting at 96.9 mph. That kind of velocity doesn’t grow on trees, especially among starting pitchers. He also stands six-foot-six with above-average extension to create an interesting physical profile. 

They might also be intrigued by his splits. He held right-handed batters to a .652 OPS in 2026. Lefties were responsible for most of the damage done against him, recording a .755 OPS with nine home runs. He could theoretically improve if he finds more success against southpaws in 2027. 

With all that said, anyone who followed the Blue Jays this past season knows they desperately need more starting pitchers they can count on. They don’t need a project arm with a sketchy injury history. Someone like Michael Soroka may also fall into this category, but has at least proven himself to be effective when he’s been healthy. 

Some of the best organizations in baseball have taken a chance on May over the past few years and none of them have been able to unlock his potential. With all due respect to the Blue Jays’ pitching development team, are they really going to turn him into an ace when the Brewers and Dodgers couldn’t? 

Whether it’s shelling out big money for Tarik Skubal, signing Michael King, or making a big bet on Trevor Rogers, Toronto should look elsewhere for May in its search for pitching help. The Blue Jays have the money to land one of the more proven options on the market this winter. 

Add us as a preferred source on Google