Why Mike Soroka is a potential bargain target for Blue Jays

Alberta native Mike Soroka is one of those athletes who will always have the words “when healthy” attached to his name. He was great in 2026 when healthy. He’s generally been a good major league pitcher when he’s been available. The issue is that he rarely is, and this past season was no exception in that regard. 

Still, the results Soroka put up feel real for several reasons. He could be a huge bargain for the Toronto Blue Jays this winter, especially if they are willing to get flexible with his role in 2027. 

Soroka recorded a 3.41 ERA with an even better 3.21 FIP across 21 starts in 2026. His 116 innings pitched with the Arizona Diamondbacks were the most he’s thrown since 2019, back when he was a young All-Star with the Atlanta Braves. 

There were several things Soroka did well. First was limiting free passes; his 6.1% walk rate ranked in the 89th percentile. He also managed an impressive 34.1% chase rate, although it didn’t translate into strikeouts as consistently as one might hope. 

That combination of command and swing-and-miss, coupled with good quality of contact metrics, helped Soroka recapture the results he flashed much earlier in his career. He was genuinely effective. 

His slurve was a huge part of his success. He threw it 32.4% of the time—as often as his fastball—and batters hit just .178 against it with a measly .226 slugging percentage. His whiff rate on this pitch was 35.5%, significantly higher than any of the other offerings in his six-pitch arsenal. 

Mike Soroka is an injury risk, but the gamble may be worth it for Blue Jays

Of course, as always with Soroka, injuries limited him in 2026 as made two separate trips to the injured list. A glute strain sidelined him in June, then he went back on the IL in late August with shoulder inflammation. He returned a few weeks later in September and finished the season healthy, however. 

These ailments were just the latest in an extensive injury resume. Those familiar with Soroka’s journey will know he tore his achilles in 2020, then tore it again in 2021 just as he was getting close to a return. He finally made it back in 2023 but has since dealt with a litany of arm and shoulder issues. 

If the Blue Jays decide to pursue Soroka this winter, they have to do so under the assumption that he won’t be healthy all year. But the innings they do get from him could be excellent, and that’s reason enough to spark up some conversations. 

What if Soroka could be utilized in a swingman role like Ross Stripling was a few years ago? Make a few starts when needed, take some time in the bullpen, and so on. Penciling him in as a Swiss Army knife could be better than hoping he’ll make 30 starts. 

The contract price would need to reflect these assumptions for it to make sense. If teams are willing to pay Soroka like a full-time starting pitcher, the Blue Jays should probably look elsewhere for a more dependable option. If he slips through the cracks, however, bringing the Canadian home could wind up being a savvy piece of business for 2027.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow