4 changes that will help the Blue Jays return to their winning ways in 2024

After a rather disappointing end to a successful 2023 season, the Toronto Blue Jays will be looking to regroup this coming offseason in preparation to compete once again for 2024. To do so, there will undoubtedly be some necessary changes that need to be made in order for the team and the organization to be successful as a whole for both the short and long term. Here, we take a look at four important areas that need to be fixed to help right the ship for the Jays.

Finding the perfect balance between offense and defense

Prior to the 2023 season, the Jays primarily used their potent offense to power their way to victory as a recipe for success. Very often though, they would encounter some lapses on defense that gave away runs to the opposition, leading to some heartbreaking losses. With the realization that defense is ultimately what wins championships, the Jays changed the makeup of their roster this season to focus more on defense rather than offense. As a result, defensive stalwarts such as Daulton Varsho and Kevin Kiermaier were added to the ballclub at the expensive of offensive threats Lourdes Gurriel Jr., Gabriel Moreno, and Teoscar Hernández.

The defense certainly made a huge difference for the Jays in 2023, with just Varsho and Kiermaier alone combining to provide the team with a whopping 47 DRS over the course of the season. However, when it came down to crunch time in the Jays’ most important games of the season, it was the offense that ended up failing them the most. In particular, they were only able to muster one run in the AL Wild Card series against the Minnesota Twins, which led to their early exit from the postseason.

So what the Jays need to do for 2024 is to insert back some consistent power and thump back into their lineup to provide the right balance with their already-improved defense and pitching. In doing so, it would make the team much more well-rounded and less likely to have just one aspect of their game severely affecting their overall effectiveness. With both defensive standouts Kiermaier and Matt Chapman heading towards free agency and Brandon Belt pondering retirement, the ideal run-producing power bat or bats the Jays could pursue should replace one or more of those vacated positions for 2024. At the same time, Varsho will be able to continue to provide elite defense in the outfield, and the much-improved Bo Bichette and Gold Glover Vladimir Guerrero Jr. will keep the infield defense at a respectable level.

The manager

Since taking over from Charlie Montoyo as manager of the Jays in 2022, John Schneider has led the team to a strong 135-101 overall winning record along with two well-earned postseason berths. So on paper, it appeared as though Schneider had been quite successful in leading the ballclub to success in the position.

However, in the midst of his current tenure with the Jays, Schneider has often made some questionable calls and decisions that ultimately affected the outcome of various ballgames. Most notably were his decisions on when he utilized his pinch-hitting and pinch-running, in addition to his management of pitchers on when they were brought in or taken out of the game. Unfortunately for Schneider, most of them ended up hurting the team more than helping it. In particular, the one that will linger in the minds of many was his pulling of starter José Berríos from the Jays’ do-or-die Game 2 of the Wild Card series against the Twins when he was practically unhittable.

Whenever decisions are made by the manager, sometimes they work out, sometimes they backfire. But in the end, the manager should own it and at the same time, have the support of the players as well no matter the outcome. But when even the players were dumbfounded, as they started to disagree and show their displeasure on such moves, the manager could essentially be losing the room and the trust of his players in the process. In Schneider’s case, he is definitely treading on thin ice right now. But if the doubt and uncertainty remains in the leading voice of the clubhouse heading into 2024, it may be the right time for a change at the helm. That way, it would re-establish the clubhouse chemistry and put everyone together on the same page once again in creating a winning formula.

The upper management

Finally, if the above changes weren’t significant enough, it may require a big shake-up at the upper management level to get the job done. When GM Ross Atkins took over the Toronto Blue Jays back in December of 2015, he managed to help direct the team to another postseason run in 2016, but subsequently entered the ballclub’s rebuilding phase starting in 2017. During that time, Atkins actually did alright in some of his moves in accelerating the rebuild by making key draft choices (Bichette and Cavan Biggio), international signings (Lourdes Gurriel Jr. and Alejandro Kirk) and trades (bringing in Hernández, Randal Grichuk, and Ken Giles). This quickly brought the Jays back into contention status by 2020.

However, despite making several moves in his continued retooling of the Jays’ roster during the past four seasons, Atkins has failed to make any further progression in terms of the organization’s playoff success. For three of the past four seasons, the Jays have bowed out of the playoffs without recording a single postseason win in the process. Not only that, he appeared to put the blame on Schneider as well when things didn’t end up going well this season in the playoffs..

The Boston Red Sox recently dismissed their chief baseball officer Chaim Bloom after a series of underwhelming seasons in recent years. The Chicago White Sox also fired their vice president Ken Williams and general manager Rick Hahn despite making the playoffs in two of the previous four seasons. If the Jays organization remains at status quo heading into the 2024 season, the same flaws and issues could potentially rear its head once again, leading to another potential frustrating season. So in order to prevent that from happening, it may finally be the time for a significant change at the upper management level to provide the organization with a new hope and a new direction for the future. In doing so, it could finally bring a championship home that everyone has been truly waiting for.