Skip to main content

Blue Jays dodged a $52.5M bullet on Dustin May, but the price he got should worry them anyway

That's a high price to pay in this market.
ByMatthew Sookram
Oct 24, 2026; Milwaukee, Wisconsin, USA;  Milwaukee Brewers pitcher Dustin May (21) throws a pitch against the Tampa Bay Rays during the fifth inning in game two of the 2026 World Series at American Family Field.  Mandatory Credit: Benny Sieu-Imagn Images
Oct 24, 2026; Milwaukee, Wisconsin, USA; Milwaukee Brewers pitcher Dustin May (21) throws a pitch against the Tampa Bay Rays during the fifth inning in game two of the 2026 World Series at American Family Field. Mandatory Credit: Benny Sieu-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Dustin May is a Chicago White Sox, and the Toronto Blue Jays should not be sulking about the acquisition, but the cost is a bit worrisome.

May agreed to a three-year, $52.5 million deal with Chicago on Tuesday morning (Nov. 17), according to FanSided's Robert Murray. The White Sox had not officially announced the signing as of this writing, but the agreement is in place, and it ends a bidding war that, as of Sunday, included nine teams — the Cubs, Nationals, Orioles, Giants, Reds, Guardians, Marlins, White Sox and Blue Jays.

The Blue Jays were right to walk away. The part that may stick with them though is what May's price says about the next arm on Toronto's list is going to cost.

May, 29, throws hard, but has never quite turned the stuff into results. He made a career-high 31 starts in 2026, split between the St. Louis Cardinals and the Milwaukee Brewers, and finished 7-9 with a 4.70 ERA and a 1.32 WHIP, striking out 144 and walking 50 in 145.1 innings.

He was decent in St. Louis (4.38 ERA in 21 starts) and worse after the deadline trade to Milwaukee (5.65 ERA in 10 starts), where his FIP jumped from 3.16 to 5.06 and he gave up seven home runs in 36.2 innings. His 2025 was worse still, a 4.96 ERA split between the Dodgers and Red Sox, and his career ERA sits at 4.12 across 470 major-league innings. He has never thrown more than 146 innings in a season.

That is the profile of a back-end starter. The White Sox just paid him $17.5 million a year for three years to be one. That could be the market setting deal and the fallout could be pricey for everyone else involved.

Dustin May's White Sox deal feels too high, raising the asking price for potential Blue Jays' targets

Starting with Freddy Peralta, who is projected to land a five-year worth anywhere between $96 million and $140 million depending on which outlet your reading. If May is worth $17.5 million a year, nothing about Peralta's market is getting cheaper, and the Blue Jays' pursuit of him just got more expensive by association.

The same could be said for starters Michael Soroka and Kris Bubic. MLB Trade Rumors projects Soroka at two years and $26 million with an opt-out, and Bubic at one year and $12.5 million. Sportsnet has Soroka at two years and $37 million, and Bubic at three years and $42 million.

The gap between those projections is why the May deal is so alarming. Nobody knows what the second tier costs yet, but May's deal pushes the market toward the high end of every one of those ranges.

Soroka threw 116 innings in 2026, his most since 2019. Bubic has a 2.98 ERA over the past four seasons. Both are better bets than May on the numbers.

This deal doesn't affect the top of the market though. Tarik Skubal, who the Blue Jays meet in California this week, is projected at eight years and $352 million by ESPN and nine years and $425 million by MLB Trade Rumors. No matter what May got, those numbers weren't moving.

The Blue Jays, who used 16 different starters in 2026 are looking at several options. If Skubal is a real target and he comes in, he goest to the top of the rotation ahead of Dylan Cease, Trey Yesavage and José Soriano. But they could also add guys at the back end behind those three since the in-house options are a collection of players overcoming injuries. Those depth arms, which would be around May's tier, just got more expensive.

So while the Blue Jays did not overpay a pitcher whose ERA is closer to 5.00 than 4.00 they will have to contend with the fact that the rest of the market may have just upped their price.

Add us as a preferred source on Google