The Toronto Blue Jays shouldn't mortgage their future in a Tarik Skubal trade

The Toronto Blue Jays will be buyers at this year’s trade deadline, barring a massive free-fall in the standings. This is a team built to win now, and the front office will likely do what it can to improve the roster if the team’s record is close to .500 or better. 

The Detroit Tigers are in a far more uncertain situation with a 20-32 record despite entering the season with high expectations of their own. They will have the biggest asset on the market to dangle if they decide to sell: two-time Cy Young Award winner Tarik Skubal. 

Skubal is currently recovering from surgery to remove loose bodies in his elbow, but is making great progress in his recovery. He’s the kind of transcendent talent capable of turning a fringe contender into a World Series favourite. He’s also an impending free agent hoping to sign the richest pitcher contract in MLB history this winter. 

There will be an epic arms race if the Tigers decide to shop Skubal. The cost to acquire his services for a stretch run will be astronomical—and that’s exactly why the Blue Jays shouldn’t be thinking about getting involved.

Depleting an already thin farm system for a rental would be a mistake

Skubal is in the midst of one of the most dominant stretches by a pitcher in recent memory, akin to the primes of Justin Verlander and Max Scherzer. He’s also proven he can pitch in the playoffs over the last few years with a 2.04 ERA across six starts. 

He would unquestionably make the Blue Jays better. A rotation of him, Dylan Cease, Trey Yesavage, Kevin Gausman, and Shane Bieber would probably be the best in franchise history. The issue isn’t the fit, but rather the team’s resources and other needs. 

The Blue Jays’ farm system is extremely top-heavy. Yesavage still ranks as the organization’s top prospect and would obviously be untouchable in a rental deal. After him are 2025 first-round pick JoJo Parker, infielder Arjun Nimmala, and promising lefty pitcher Johnny King. 

Detroit would likely ask for two of those three, knowing other contending teams with deeper farm systems could offer better packages. Giving up Parker and King for someone who is no guarantee to re-sign would be an astronomical risk. 

There is also a matter of need to consider with the Blue Jays likely to already have four playoff-level starters on their roster come October. They made it all the way to the World Series last year with a far weaker group than what they have now. 

Would the Blue Jays be good enough to win a championship if Skubal was their only major addition? That’s debatable given the state of the lineup and bullpen. They would probably be better off allocating their resources towards an impact bat or a high-leverage reliever.

Going all in on Yordan Alvarez or Josh Hader if the Houston Astros decide to sell would probably be a better choice. The same could be said for the Arizona Diamondbacks and Ketel Marte if they fall out of the National League playoff race. 
Ultimately, while it’s fun to dream about Skubal pitching meaningful games for the Blue Jays, he’s not the missing piece—there are wiser moves to be made.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow