How the Blue Jays' best deadline deals stack up against their rivals in the AL East

With the 2026 trade deadline now in the rearview mirror, the Toronto Blue Jays, and the rest of the AL East can look towards the remainder of the season now that their rosters are mostly set.

Every trade deadline comes with excitement, confusion and chaos, and this year it was certainly no different. There were deals that felt inevitable, big surprises and real headscratchers. A question that is always asked is, what team made the best moves? Looking in the AL East specifically, there are definitely varying levels of quality from deal to deal, and thus some stand above others.

Seeing as the AL East has multiple current contenders, and other teams that could compete in the very near future, big moves were inevitable, and some of these teams swung hard. The Blue Jays were no different, making multiple moves including acquiring one of the best players and assets available.

Ranking the the top moves made from teams in the AL East division

1. Baltimore Orioles acquire prospect haul for Adley Rutschman

The Orioles entered the season looking to reclaim a postseason spot after a big offseason, but once the season took a wrong turn, it seemed obvious what the course of action should be.

Rutschman has been a cornerstone for the Orioles since he made his big league debut, accumulating 17.3 fWAR over parts of five seasons with the club. After a down season in 2025, he rebuilt his value with a 115 wRC+ and 5.3 fWAR per 650 plate appearances. Trade rumours surrounded the former first overall pick once the Orioles agreed to a long term extension with catcher Samuel Basallo.

They pulled the trigger Monday, acquiring three prospects, who now respectively rank first, sixth and seventh in the Orioles system according to MLB Pipeline. Anthony Enyanson, now their top prospect, ranks as a top 50 prospect in all of baseball. The Orioles also acquired major league catcher Carlos Narváez and a player to be named later.

Rutschman is one of the better catchers in baseball this season, and while he is under team control through 2027, the prospect haul makes this an undeniable win for the Orioles.

2. Blue Jays acquire José Soriano in blockbuster move

After trading away fan favourite Kevin Gausman, the Blue Jays were clearly sellers, however the team made the wise move to add some talent that can help them in 2027 and beyond, acquiring Los Angeles Angels ace José Soriano.

The Blue Jays did have to part with baseball’s 43rd ranked prospect in Arjun Nimmala in the deal, as well as two other prospects not ranked in the organization's top 30. Trading Nimmala is a tough blow, however it is more than worth it for Soriano, who is a legit front end arm under team control through 2028.

Soriano has pitched to 3.29 ERA and 3.79 FIP in 123 innings this season and ranks 19th among AL pitchers with 2.1 fWAR. He possesses a deep arsenal including a four-seam fastball that averages over 97 mph, and is elite at limiting damage with a groundball rate ranking in the 90th percentile.

It is also worth noting that Soriano will go from pitching to catcher Logan O’Hoppe, who ranked dead last in FRV (-14) and Framing Runs (-11) among catchers, to pitching to Alejandro Kirk and Brandon Valenzuela who are two of the league's top defensive catchers.

3. Tampa Bay Rays snag breakout catcher from Miami Marlins

The Rays made the move Monday to acquire breakout catcher Liam Hicks from the Marlins in an interesting move.

Hicks slashed .282/.363/.432 with a .795 OPS and 119 wRC+ before being traded. The Rays traded three prospects to the Marlins who now rank as the organization’s 10th, 22nd and 23rd prospects respectively.

The Rays needed depth in their lineup that ranks 15th in baseball in runs scored, and Hicks helps do just that, however the big wins come elsewhere. The three prospects the Rays gave up are not very high a price, none of the prospects ranked in the Rays top 15, which makes the package rather light. Hicks is also under team control through 2030.

Hicks does not seem to profile as a catcher long term, as Statcast ranks him as below average in both blocking and framing. He likely profiles as a first baseman or designated hitter long term, but acquiring such a player for a low price is the type of organizational win that the Rays are known for.

4. New York Yankees acquire slugger from Washington Nationals

The Yankees made their trade deadline mark when they acquired lefty power hitter Luis García Jr., adding one of baseball’s best sluggers this season.

García had already been a productive player in the past, but he has taken it to a new level this season, posting a 134 wRC+ and slugging 23 home runs before getting traded. He currently ranks fifth in ISO and second in SLG.

The Yankees desperately needed offense. The team has been without generational talent Aaron Judge since May 31 due to a rib injury. Since then, the Yankees offense ranks dead last in wRC+ (87), 26th in runs scored (214) and position player fWAR (4.3).

García’s offensive jump is fueled by an increase in bat speed, launch angle optimization and pulling more balls in the air. He is also under control through the 2027 season.

The best asset the Yankees gave up was the organization’s 14th ranked prospect in right handed pitcher Jack Cebert, with the package as a whole being a quantity based package. The lack of real valuable assets leaving the Yankees, García’s control and positive improvements in process, makes this a win for the Yankees.

5. Blue Jays acquire flamethrowing prospect for Jeff Hoffman

The Blue Jays capped off an eventful trade deadline by shipping off reliever Jeff Hoffman to the Minnesota Twins for a package of prospects. Hoffman had been putting together a nice year for the Blue Jays, pitching to a 2.49 FIP and 2.43 SIERA, with an additional year of team control adding value to him as an asset.

The Blue Jays acquired three prospects, most notably Dasan Hill, who ranked 95th on Baseball America’s top 100 prospects lists to begin 2026. The Blue Jays also acquired John Klein and Dameury Pena in the deal.

The big prize in the deal is Hill. His prospect value has seen a decline this season due to control issues, sporting a 7.40 BB/9 so far in high-A this season, however his value comes from his top of the line stuff. Despite control issues, Hill has notched a 15.40 K/9 over 45 innings this season, thanks to an arsenal of pitches that are all capable of missing bats. 

Hill has the upside of a middle-end starter, however even as a relief arm would likely be electric due to a fastball that can touch 99 mph. If Hill can iron out some of the control issues, he shoots up the top 100 prospects list. The Blue Jays have a surplus of talent in their bullpen, and adding a high upside arm like Hill, plus another MLB ready arm in Klein, makes this a value win for the Blue Jays.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow