Blue Jays injured list racking up millions of dollars and potential wins

Ask any Toronto Blue Jays fan what's behind the team's dismal 7-11 start (featuring a -25 run differential), and you'll get one consensus answer: injuries.

This team hasn't just been hit by an injury plague; they're being drowned by it, losing players left and right and struggling to keep up with the roster demands that so many health issues create. At the moment, five starting pitchers, one reliever, and four hitters are recovering from various ailments while on the injured list, which has forced guys like Eloy Jiménez and Patrick Corbin into some uncomfortably high-leverage situations recently. Oh, and it's only mid-April.

But it's not just wins that these injuries have cost the Blue Jays. There's an entire payroll's worth of salaries currently out of action.

In terms of luxury tax calculations, nearly $105 million of the team's $290 in committments (roughly 36.2%) isn't being put to use. Given that, it's almost a miracle they've managed to stay this close to .500.

Blue Jays must fight to stay afloat until their expensive reinforcements arrive

Frustratingly, some of the most expensive members of the roster are the ones expected to take the longest to return. Cody Ponce is more than likely out for the year after suffering an ACL injury, while both Shane Bieber and Anthony Santander are trapped on the 60-day IL. Those three alone are making $43 million combined in 2026.

If the money isn't gobsmacking enough, the WAR calculations from the missing contributors are really going to make your head spin. The following is every player currently on the IL and their 2025 fWAR in parenthesis.

Season-Ending Injuries:
Bowden Francis (-0.8)
Cody Ponce (N/A — played in NPB)

60-day IL:
Shane Bieber (0.3)
Anthony Santander (-0.9)

10/15-day IL:
Alejandro Kirk (4.7)
Addison Barger (2.2)
George Springer (5.2)
José Berrios (1.3)
Trey Yesavage (0.4)

That's nearly 13 wins worth of production, and those figures don't account for the heroics of Yesavage in the postseason. This has truly been just a mind-numbing start to the season.

The good news is that reinforcements may be soon to arrive. Trey Yesavage looked good in his last rehab start and could make his long-awaited season debut as soon as next week, and both Barger and Springer are hopeful for minimum stays on the IL.

Their respective returns won't fix all that ails the Blue Jays, but it'd be a start to repairing the damages of this 7-11 opening act.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow