Blue Jays fans catching heat on social media over ridiculous All-Star voting

You can't say fans of the Toronto Blue Jays aren't passionate. The first round of All-Star ballots have been revealed and the Blue Jays, thanks to the fans vote, are very well represented. If the voting ended today, the Blue Jays would have a representative at every position except the outfield.

Alejandro Kirk is second in voting among AL catchers. Kazuma Okamoto (3B), Andrés Giménez (SS), and George Springer (DH) are also second at their respective positions while Vladimir Guerrero Jr. (1B) and Ernie Clement (2B) are leading theirs.

As a fan of the Blue Jays this is awesome to see, but on the other hand, it sort of makes a mockery of the spirit of the fan vote, and many people online were quick to point that out. While a few of them are deserving to be in these spots based on their 2026 performance, it's obvious that two things are happening. One, the Blue Jays players are getting recognized for their performances last year and into the World Series and two, fans in Canada are flooding the ballot boxes.

Only a few Blue Jays are having "All-Star" seasons in 2026

Of the Blue Jays on the list, only Clement and Okamoto are really earning their votes. Among qualified hitters, Clement sits second in home runs (7), has the lowest strikeout percentage (9.8%), has the highest batting average (.304), wRC+ (116), and SLG (.460) among his second base peers. He's also second in the entire American League in hits (84) and leads in doubles (20).

As for Okamoto, he's hit the second most home runs by a third baseman in the AL this season (15) tied with Junior Caminero of the Tampa Bay Rays and one back of Miguel Vargas of the Chicago White Sox (as of Jun. 16). The "rookie" Okamoto is getting his first taste of MLB action and while he isn't the player the Blue Jays had envisioned when they signed him, he's doing things they probably didn't expect either. He's slashing .235/.314/.447 with a 111 wRC+.

On the other hand, Guerrero Jr. and Springer certainly haven't had All-Star caliber seasons. While Guerrero has hit the ball often, 54 of his 69 hits (78%) have been singles and he's sent just one ball over the fence since May 17th. Springer is slashing .208/.303/.354, numbers much lower than his Silver Slugger winning campaign a year ago when he led the Blue Jays with 32 home runs and a .959 OPS.

Giménez also fits into this category. The Blue Jays' shortstop has had some great bursts of offensive production and is still productive defensively (7.7 defensive fWAR) he's only produced the 13th highest fWAR (0.9) among AL shortstops and sports a 71 wRC+.

Lastly, unlike Guerrero, Springer and Giménez, Kirk has been really good at the plate, but he's played in less than ten games this season due to a fractured thumb. Of course, this isn't sitting well with fans of other teams. Not many are buying that guys like Vladdy, Springer and Kirk are having All-Star season's and you can't blame them.

But this is the door that's left open when the voting comes from the fans and it is not new to see Blue Jays fans over taking the voting process and getting their guys to the top of the charts. As long as this system is in place, the All-Star game may, in fact, be missing some actual All-Stars.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow