Blue Jays fan favourite Davis Schneider optioned again as Toronto continues to slump

The Toronto Blue Jays saw the MLB debut of another one of their top prospects on Saturday when Sean Keys made the start at first base against the Texas Rangers. Keys had been tearing things up in the Blue Jays minor league system this year, so Toronto was hoping that he could inject some of that offense into their lineup.

The 23-year-old infielder would go 1-for-4 and score his first ever big league run, but it wasn’t enough as the Jays continue to slump, losing their third consecutive game to the Rangers and fifth consecutive game overall.

The promotion of Keys also came at the expense of a Blue Jays fan favourite as Davis Schneider was optioned for a second time this season to the minors in Triple-A Buffalo. He will now have to prove his worth to work his way back up to the majors once again.

Has Davis Schneider been usurped by top prospects in the Blue Jays system?

Schneider certainly hasn’t been enjoying his 2026 campaign to date. On the season, the 27-year-old utilityman has compiled a disappointing .153 average, .578 OPS, along with just 16 runs scored, three home runs and 12 RBIs in 49 total games played with the Blue Jays.

He had actually been a bit better of late during his second stint up with the team. In those 11 games of action, Schneider was batting .222 with a .760 OPS, with three runs scored, two doubles, two home runs and four RBIs. However, the bulk of that offensive impact came in a span of two games between June 14 and June 16 where he registered two home runs and three RBIs. As a result, the Jays were likely looking for more offensive consistency at the plate.

With that in mind, it made sense to give Keys his chance. After all, the Blue Jays No. 14 prospect according to MLB Pipeline had been by far Toronto’s top hitter in the minor leagues so far this season, and it isn’t even close. In 67 games split between Double-A New Hampshire and Buffalo, Keys has amassed a .284/.409/.619/1.028 slash line with 55 runs scored, 14 doubles, 21 home runs, 54 RBIs and seven stolen bases.

So for a Jays team that had lost five in a row, Toronto was certainly hoping that he could bring some of that overwhelming power production into their mix to help turn things around.

After seeing the arrivals of Brandon Valenzuela and Yohendrick Pinango earlier in the season, the Blue Jays will look forward to seeing the potential impact of Keys and what he could provide to their struggling lineup going forward. As for Schneider, we probably haven’t seen the last of him just yet. But his time to leave a lasting impression to maintain a secure big league gig with Toronto could be running out soon.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow