Rookie Yohendrick Piñango has already made this trade a win for the Blue Jays

The Toronto Blue Jays are getting everything they could have wanted and then some out of Yohendrick Piñango in 2026. Ever since his big league debut on April 26, the rookie out of Venezuela has done everything the team could have asked of him as he has hit .375/.412/.438 with an OPS of .849. While he's still looking for his first big league home run he's out-hit everyone on the team, and it's not particularly close.

That comes with the caveat that Piñango has only 34 at-bats over that time, while his teammates have upwards of 60+, but when he has been called upon, he has delivered. The 23-year-old left-handed hitting outfielder has been so good in his short MLB stint that he's been more valuable than the player the Blue Jays traded to acquire him - Nate Pearson.

When looking at the bWAR analytic specifically, Piñango's career bWAR of 0.3 is already higher than what Pearson, a former first round Blue Jays' draft pick, has accumulated in his time in the big leagues. Pearson's career -1.0 bWAR is reflection on both a failure by the Blue Jays front office, and a success since they managed to make up for it.

Pearson still battling for his big league career

The failure on the Blue Jays' part is that Pearson is just one of a long line of players the Blue Jays drafted that never panned out. While you can say that about a lot of general managers in the Major Leagues, the Blue Jays track record of drafting and developing starting pitchers has been awful. Pearson, taken with the 28th overall pick of the 2017 draft, was Ross Atkins' second crack at the can that is the MLB draft.

Pearson was considered to be a very good choice by the second year GM of the Blue Jays at that time. The industry loved his fastball and thought he had the makeup of an ace in the making. But it didn't work out that way, and outside of two seasons of Alek Manoah, the Blue Jays have still yet to draft a starting pitcher that has had a measurable impact on the big league roster.

They've had some relative success with relievers, but 2026 will be Atkins' tenth MLB draft with the Blue Jays and if it wasn't for his work elsewhere on the roster, and through trades and free agency signings, his draft track record would be enough to send him searching for a job elsewhere.

Pearson played in 93 games with the Blue Jays, but that only includes five starts. Across 115.2 innings pitched he accumulated a 5.21 ERA. While his 130 strikeouts are impressive, he had control issues walking hitters at a 4.7 BB9 rate and he also had a 1.461 WHIP.

At the 2024 deadline, the Blue Jays shipped Pearson to the Chicago Cubs in exchange for Josh Rivera and Piñango. Pearson responded well to his new change of scenery. In 19 games down the stretch, Pearson pitched in 26.1 innings and accumulated a 2.73 ERA allowing only eight earned runs and four walks while striking out 23 batters. However, he only pitched in 14.2 innings the following year, racked up an ERA of 9.20 in various stints with the Cubs and was eventually released in September.

He signed a one-year, $1.35 million contract in October with the Houston Astros, but has been recovering from elbow surgery and has just begun his rehab assignment in their system. Pearson, at 29-years-old still has time to figure it out, but if Piñango stays on this path he's going to give the Blue Jays absolutely no regrets about this deal.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow