Two very different deals have offered a first read on what controllable pitching is worth this winter and the Toronto Blue Jays are now figuring out what that means for their collection of young arms.
The offseason trade market got going in a hurry on Wednesday. The Kansas City Royals sent third baseman Maikel Garcia to the Seattle Mariners in a six-player deal that MLB.com called the biggest blockbuster of the winter so far. A day later, the Colorado Rockies acquired right-handers Luis Castillo and Davis Martin from the Chicago White Sox.
While neither trade involved the Blue Jays, it does give them some information at how clubs are pricing pitching. The Blue Jays have some holes to fill on their big league roster and some of their most tradeable assets are their minor league arms.
Seattle gets a premium player as Royals bet on the upside
Seattle gave up two capable starters in Bryce Miller and Logan Evans, along with left-handed reliever José A. Ferrer. In return, the Mariners got Garcia, a 26-year-old third baseman and 2025 Gold Glove winner who is under contract through 2030.
They also landed two pitchers in James McArthur and L.P. Langevin. According to MLB.com, the deal started when Royals GM J.J. Picollo said Kansas City would move Garcia if Seattle was open to trading from its rotation.
We have a six-player trade between the Royals and Mariners headlined by 3B Maikel Garcia and RHP Bryce Miller!
— FOX Sports: MLB (@MLBONFOX) November 18, 2026
The full trade reported by @Ken_Rosenthal pic.twitter.com/pbijW25c4r
The pitchers Seattle moved are useful, but they also come with question marks. Miller is 28, has three years of control left and was 4-10 with a 4.17 ERA in 2026. He has a 4.82 ERA over 209 innings since he posted a 2.94 ERA in 2024. Miller also had a couple of strong outings against the Blue Jays in the 2025 ALCS and looked to be a core piece of the future of the Mariners rotation.
Evans, meantime, missed all of 2026 after elbow surgery. A starter with an up-and-down record, an injured arm and a reliever were enough to bring back a difference maker at a premium defensive position. That is an encouraging sign for any team with pitching depth to spend.
Rockies-White Sox: a salary dump muddies the comparison
Colorado’s trade is harder to read. The Rockies sent left-hander Sean Sullivan, now the White Sox’s No. 27 prospect, and Douglas Veliz, a 17-year-old catcher for Castillo and Martin. Martin went 9-8 with a 3.95 ERA in 29 games in 2026 and is under control through 2030. Sullivan, meanwhile, posted an 8.87 ERA in his first taste of the majors. That lasted six starts before a left shoulder injury and elbow pain kept him off the mound from July onwards.
That looks like a low price for a league-average starter with four years of control. But Colorado also took on all of Castillo’s 2027 salary of $22.75 million, with a $25 million vesting option for 2028. After Castillo posted a 5.85 ERA between Seattle and Chicago last year, the Rockies are hoping he bounces back in what is arguably the toughest pitching environment in the majors.
The Colorado Rockies have acquired RHP Luis Castillo and RHP Davis Martin from the Chicago White Sox in exchange for LHP Sean Sullivan and C Douglas Veliz.
— Colorado Rockies (@Rockies) November 20, 2026
Welcome to Colorado Luis and Davis! pic.twitter.com/AL9Rx70w1J
Prospects Johnny King and Nolan Perry allows Blue Jays to make their own high profile trades
FanGraphs’ Blue Jays Top 38 prospects list is built around pitching. Five of the top six names are pitchers: Johnny King (No. 2, 50 FV), Nolan Perry (No. 3, 45+), Cole Carlon (No. 4, 45+), Dasan Hill (No. 5, 45) and Ricky Tiedemann (No. 6, 45). Jake Bloss sits at No. 9 with a 40+ grade. The only non-pitcher in the top six is JoJo Parker at No. 1.
If there's anything to get excited about it's the price Seattle paid for Garcia. With pitching the key return, and Kansas City was willing to hand over a Gold Glove-caliber guy who can impact the lineup everyday, there's a chance the Blue Jays can aim higher with their depth.
The case for being less excited comes from the other deal. While Miller is expected to step straight into Kansas City’s rotation, and Martin and Castillo are expected to anchor Colorado’s, the Blue Jays’ best young arms are mostly in Double-A or lower. But that also means there could be more upside to sell.
Perry and Guerrera are so highly coveted that the Blue Jays added them to the 40-man roster earlier this week. Bloss’ stock fell after another injury-hit year, but he bounced back in the Arizona Fall League. A similar story can be told about Tiedemann, just replace the AFL with a couple of stints in the big leagues late last season.
The Blue Jays’ best bet is probably to use their top pitching prospects, such as King and Perry, as the centrepiece of a bigger trade for an impact player. It could be a risky move, as is the case with dealing any young prospect, but the Blue Jays need a jolt in their lineup and clearly teams are willing to move those pieces if it means getting back some arms.
