Top 5 wild, painful and unforgettable finishes to Blue Jays’ games in 2025

The Blue Jays played in some of the craziest games in 2025
The Toronto Blue Jays played in some of the greatest MLB games in 2025.
The Toronto Blue Jays played in some of the greatest MLB games in 2025. | Vaughn Ridley/GettyImages
1 of 3

Last week, MLB posted a list of the 20 best finishes from the 2025 season. The Toronto Blue Jays cracked the list five times. While we take a stroll down memory lane, fair warning, some of these may bring back bad memories for Blue Jays fans.

The five Blue Jays' games from 2025 that may or may not be worth rewatching

5. July 2: 11-9 win vs. the New York Yankees

The Blue Jays could not have gotten off to a better start against the Yankees on July 2. Toronto racked up five runs before recording an out, thanks to an RBI double from Alejandro Kirk and a three-run home run from Addison Barger. Later in the first inning, Davis Schneider hit a two-run home run, the first of two homers for Schneider in the game.

But after falling behind 7-0 in the first inning, the Yankees fought all the way back. When the Blue Jays came to the plate in the bottom of the eighth, the score was tied 9-9. Barger came to bat with runners on second and third with two outs. Devin Williams threw a wild pitch, giving the Blue Jays the go-ahead run. Barger then hit an RBI single, handing the Blue Jays an 11-9 win. The win tied the Blue with the Yankees for the top spot in the AL East after being eight games back of New York on May 28.

Loading recommendations... Please wait while we load personalized content recommendations