What could the Blue Jays get in a trade for one of their superstars?

2 of 3

Okay Blue Jays fans, we need to talk …

Saturday’s dramatic comeback aside, it’s hard to deny that the 2024 season is teetering on the brink of outright calamity. Sitting last in the AL East behind what to this point has been one of the worst offenses in franchise history, the Jays are clinging by their fingernails to any sort of relevance.

But it’s actually worse than that.

Down years happen. What makes the Jays’ current predicament so particularly distressing is that both of its two current faces of the franchise – Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and Bo Bichette – are entering the final year of their contract in 2025.

That neither has yet been signed long-term is somewhat shocking, especially considering where the game of baseball has gone in recent years. Think about it – Ronald Acuña Jr., Julio Rodríguez, Fernando Tatís Jr., Corbin Carroll, Bobby Witt Jr., Wander Franco, Michael Harris II, even Keibert Ruiz … all signed to long-term extensions before their 24th birthday.

But not Vladdy and Bo.

What this means is that if they do not sign an extension this offseason, then 2025 effectively becomes a lame duck season, with every game representing another tick of the clock in the countdown to their eventual exit in free agency.

In fact, if they don’t sign an extension this offseason, they may not be on the team at all in 2025. The Jays front office has shown itself anxious to trade beloved star players before they reach the final year of their contract – think Lourdes Gurriel and Teoscar Hernández, or, for that matter, Marcus Stroman – so why wouldn’t they be preparing to do the same with Vladdy and Bo instead of losing them for nothing?

As painful as it might be to hear, we may now be in the final days of the Guerrero/Bichette era in Toronto.

Which brings us back to where we are now. Is the 2024 season over? Is there really no hope the Jays can turn things around? If so, well, put it this way, the further from free agency you can trade Guerrero and Bichette, the more value they are likely to have.

It’s indicative of how poorly the 2024 season has gone so far that this is now a topic of discussion, but here we are – if the Jays were to trade Vladdy or Bo, or both, what could they expect to get in return?

What could the Blue Jays get in a trade for one of their superstars?

Here is a small piece of good news. Given their age, Vlad (25-years-old) and Bo (26) occupy an unusual position for potential trade candidates – established enough in the game that they would appeal to contenders, while still young enough that they would appeal to rebuilding teams looking to accelerate the process. Simply, the pool of potential suitors would extend from the very top of the standings to the very bottom.

As such, there are two broad categories of trade the Jays might find on the table – on one hand, deals with teams looking to go for it right now in exchange for prospects, and on the other, moves for an older star from a team entering a rebuild.

What might each category look like? Well, let’s take a look.

Trade Guerrero/Bichette for Prospects?

It is not difficult to find contending teams who might jump at the chance to get their hands on a Blue Jays star right now.

Think about Bo Bichette sliding into the Braves lineup at a shortstop position which has been little more than patchwork since they lost Dansby Swanson in free agency. Imagine the Twins with Vlad Jr. at first, instead of the 38-year-old journeyman who currently occupies the position. Are the Astros going to find their way back into it as everyone expects? If so, well, their 37-year-old first baseman Jose Abreu has been one of the worst hitters in the game this season.

A trade with teams like this would surely bring a cavalcade of prospects in return. But what kind of prospects? Recent years have provided a couple of obvious comparables for what the Jays might expect.

For Bo Bichette, one might look at the Mets' 2021 trade for Francisco Lindor. Like Bo, Lindor was headed into his age-27 season, and the last year of contract. Yes, he had shown more power than Bo, and was certainly a better defender, but he also had a lower average and a similar OPS.

In return for Lindor and pitcher Carlos Carrasco – who was either a valuable piece of the trade or a salary dump, depending on who you ask – the Mets sent four players to Cleveland, including Amed Rosario, who had been the number one prospect in all of baseball and had just begun to establish himself in the bigs, as well as top 100 prospect Andrés Giménez, and two additional prospects ranked in the Mets’ top ten.

For Vlad, the best recent comparable is probably the 2022 Matt Olson trade. He moved from the A’s to the Braves entering his age-28 season, a two-time 30-homer man and Gold Glover, with a similar career OPS to where Vladdy currently sits. In return for Olson, Oakland received two top 50 prospects in Shea Langeliers and Cristian Pache, as well as two additional prospects in the Braves' top-10.

If you’re a little more down on Vladdy and Bo, then perhaps a better comparable for both would be the 2018 trade of Christian Yelich. Once one of baseball’s top prospects, Yelich broke in with the Marlins as a 21-year-old, and through his first four full seasons had been … pretty good. He hadn’t quite developed the power the Marlins were expecting, topping out at 21 home runs, but he had been a solid player with an average north of .280 and an OPS between .764 and .859.

Heading into his age-26 season, Yelich was traded to the Brewers for four players, including the #13 ranked prospect in the game, Lewis Brinson, and two additional top 100 prospects in Isan Díaz and Monte Harrison, along with another less touted pitching prospect.

You may notice something glaring here, namely that none of the prospects mentioned have yet developed into anything special. At this point, longstanding Jays fans will probably tilt their heads to the sky and curse the name of Kyle Drabek (once the headline piece in the Roy Halladay trade), or at least get a twisted grin on their face as they remember Brett Lawrie et al. for Josh Donaldson.

But this isn’t a debate over the value of trading established players for prospects, it’s merely an estimation of what the Jays might get right now for one of their stars. And the expected haul is relatively clear – two or three top 100 prospects, preferably headlined by a true blue chipper, and one or two additional flyers further down the rankings.

Trade Guerrero/Bichette for an established star?

What about if the Jays went in the other direction? Look around the league and you’ll notice numerous teams with older superstars who seem destined for a reset, if not a rebuild.

Of course, the most obvious name which will jump into mind is Mike Trout. Yes, he is currently out for the year. Yes, he has his famous no-trade clause, and has insisted he wants to finish his career in sunny southern California. But with the Angles having lost Ohtani and once again sitting at the bottom of the standings, you’d have to think that if they were given the opportunity to bring Vladdy to the place his father dominated for so many years, well, they’d at least have to call Trout and ask, right?

How about the Mets, whose billionaire-backed spending spree hasn’t really gotten them anywhere. With Pete Alonso a free agent after this year, might they be anxious to trade for his replacement? Heck, if the Jays front office loves Alonso, maybe they would offer a one-for-one deal for Guerrero, then sign him to the extension they never put in front of Vladdy.

And we don’t even have to mention the San Diego Padres, who despite seeming to collect superstars for fun, are mired in their second consecutive year of .500 baseball. We know the Jays have kicked the tires on both Jake Cronenworth and Ha-Seong Kim in the past. What about a 2-for-1 deal?

Look through the league and you will surely find more names which might make sense. The point is, if the Jays are preparing for life without Vladdy and Bo, but don’t want to start all over again – particularly after pouring hundreds of millions of dollars into a ballpark which now needs to be filled – they might just be able to turn a current face of the franchise into the next one.

Should the Blue Jays trade one of their superstars?

So, what do you think? Is there a move out there for Guerrero or Bichette that makes sense? More importantly, should the Jays be actively looking to pull the plug on the current iteration of the franchise? If so, well, the day will be something between bittersweet and tragic.

Or, you know, Vladdy and Bo could go on an absolute tear, save the season, then sign for ten years each. That would work too …

Let me know your take on the platform formerly known as Twitter – @WriteFieldDeep.

Home / Toronto Blue Jays News