The best Toronto Blue Jays gifts for fans this Christmas season

It seems like Halloween just wrapped up - and the turkey isn't even thawed yet - but there's no time to wait. Those sleigh bells are about to start ringing and you've got Toronto Blue Jays fans in your life that need a great gift under the Christmas tree. 

Don't wait until the last snowflake falls to find that perfect gift. Instead, get your shopping taken care of early - then sit back and relax between Thanksgiving and Christmas morning. 

We're going to help you make each present a grand slam with our list of must-have gifts for Toronto Blue Jays fans. 

Let's get started. 

Fanatics
Fanatics

Toronto Blue Jays Nike Replica Player Name Jersey

Look, every fan needs at least one jersey in the rotation. Make sure all your friends have a power hitter in their closet lineup.

Shop replica jerseys at Fanatics.

BreakingT
BreakingT

Unique, Awesome and MLBPA-licensed shirts from BreakingT

BreakingT aims to let customers ‘Wear The Moment’ with awesome shirts designed in realtime to match the most exciting and viral moments. They are officially licensed by the MLBPA, NBPA, WNBPA and more.

Shop BreakingT.

Fanatics
Fanatics

Toronto Blue Jays Nike Performance Pullover Hoodie

Help a friend stay nice and cozy this winter... because it's cold out there! A hoodie will help.

Order this Nike hoodie at Fanatics for $79.99.

Amazon
Amazon

Across The Board Baseball Game

Carved out of maple, this tabletop board game not only feels hefty and study, but is a ton of fun for fans of all ages. 

Order at Amazon for $65.

Dugout Mugs
Dugout Mugs

Dugout Mugs

Is there something cooler for a baseball fan to drink out of than an actual baseball bat? Nah, we didn't think so.

Shop Dugout Mugs, starting at $29.99.

Fanatics
Fanatics

2023 Topps Chrome Baseball Factory Sealed Monster Box

Each box contains seven packs with six cards per pack. Ten exclusive parallels are also included - with the chance to find autographs of the biggest names in baseball. 

Order at Fanatics for $59.99.

Fanatics
Fanatics

Toronto Blue Jays New Era Game Authentic Collection On-Field 59FIFTY Fitted Hat

A nice hat is essential for any look. So if you're going to give someone a hat - you might as well make it the industry standard. 

Order at Fanatics for $41.99.

Taylor Chip
Taylor Chip

Taylor Chip: Delightfully Perfect Cookies

A tasty treat for the holidays? Who says no to that? Taylor Chip cookies are insanely delicious and can be served in a number of ways (from chilled in the fridge to piping hot out of the stove or microwave) - and they're all tasty. 

Taylor Chip provided me with a box to review earlier this fall. They were great. Chewy, dense and massive (each cookie is at least 5.5 ounces) - these cookies are big enough to share (but I never wanted to). In fact, the last 'brookie' almost caused a fight in my home. 

You can select your own cookies, or go with one of their pre-selected options. You can't go wrong (they have nearly 30 varieties), but my personal favorite was the sugar cookie. 

Shop Taylor Chip bundles. 

Amazon
Amazon

The Only Rule Is It Has To Work by Ben Lindbergh and Sam Miller

Lindbergh and Miller are baseball analysts who are presented with the opportunity to run an actual baseball team - the Sonoma Stompers. They're free to run the team however they see fit (typically based on their analytics) in a fantasy-baseball-in-real-life experiment. 

Can they take the Stompers to the title? Or do they end up striking out? 

Order at Amazon for $14.99.

Fanatics
Fanatics

Toronto Blue Jays Fanatics Pack Golf-Themed Gift Box - $105+ Value

A $105 value, but that's not the price tag. You can get someone a pretty sweet golf set (that includes a '47 Brand hat, cotton towel, double sided poker chip ball marker, tees, hat pin, repair tool and golf balls) for just $80.

Order at Fanatics for $79.99.

Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays, FanSiders! 

This post contains affiliate links, where we may receive a percentage of any sale made from the links on this page. Prices and availability are accurate as of the time of publication.

Schedule