Reliving 4 best playoff runs in Blue Jays history while fans are stuck watching from home in 2024

It has been hard being a Toronto Blue Jays fan for the past three seasons, watching the Jays consistently fail in their quest for an exciting and deep playoff run. Back in 2022, their dream was utterly destroyed in an awkward sequence that involved Jays shortstop Bo Bichette colliding with outfielder George Springer. In the process, it allowed the Seattle Mariners to come all the way back from being down 8-1 at one point to win 10-9 in Game 2 of the AL Wild Card Series. The complete collapse took away from the strong pitching performance by Jays’ ace Kevin Gausman, as well as Teoscar Hernández’s two-home run performance. The comeback stung even more when it hit the record books by becoming the second largest comeback in MLB postseason history.

Then came another playoff run in which the Jays came up way short once again the following year in 2023. Their offense was stymied by the stingy Minnesota Twins’ pitching staff, as they held the Jays to just one run over two games in the AL Wild Card Series. This time around, the highlight (or “low”light) of their demise came when starter José Berríos was taken out of the game by Jays’ manager John Schneider despite cruising along and shutting down the Twins’ hitters. The moment he was removed, the Twins quickly pushed two runs across as it was all that they needed to secure a 2-0 game and series win over Toronto.

This season, the circumstances have been even worse, as the Jays failed to even make the postseason completely. However, despite their disappointing showings in recent years,, it hasn’t been all that bad when taking a look at some of the Jays’ historical playoff runs from the past. In fact, there have actually been a few exciting and successful ones that are worth re-living the moments through once again as a true Jays’ fan.

As a result, let’s take a look back at four of the best postseason runs made by the Jays in franchise history while fans can remorse in being stuck watching from home for this year.

1993 – The blast into history

With the Jays and their faithful now hungry for more following a successful 1992 season, the team headed into the postseason once again led by the renowned Jays’ offensive gauntlet known as “WAMCO”. That group was made up by Devon White, Alomar, Paul Molitor, Joe Carter and John Olerud. With the dynamic Rickey Henderson and pitching stud Dave Stewart also added into the mix, the Jays were looking to repeat as champions in 1993.

For the ALCS, the Jays faced off against the Chicago White Sox, who ended a six-year run in which either the Athletics or Minnesota Twins represent the AL West in the postseason. Despite their playoff inexperience, the White Sox were still a tough opponent, led by a boatload of stars in Frank Thomas, Ozzie Guillen, Robin Ventura, Tim Raines and Carlton Fisk. 

After the Jays went up 2-0 in the series following two big road wins, the White Sox came right back to tie the series at two on Toronto’s home soil. From there, the Jays got their game together to punch out two more wins to eventually take the series 4-2. In the process, they had to defeat eventual AL Cy Young winner Jack McDowell in two of the games to get through.

Now back in the World Series, the Jays had a new foe that year in the Philadelphia Phillies. The Phillies spoiled the 104-win Braves’ chance to get back into a championship rematch with Toronto by defeating them in the NLCS. The championship finals was characterized by its high-scoring affair, with a total of 81 runs scored during the six-game matchup. The turning point of the World Series came in Game 4 with the Jays up two games to one. The Phillies held a 14-9 lead heading into the final two innings, as they appeared well on their way to even up the the series at two. However, a six-run eighth inning completed an improbable comeback for Toronto as they took a commanding 3-1 lead in the series. 

That helped set up one of the best ever moments in postseason history as Joe Carter hit a walk-off three-run homer in Game 6 to make the Jays back-to-back World Series champions. His home run was the second walk-off homer in MLB history to end a World Series, and the first ever in come-from-behind fashion. That elusive iconic moment still lives to this day with legendary call by play-by-play announcer Tom Cheek’s “Touch ‘em all Joe, you’ll never hit a bigger home run in your life”.

2015 – The bat flip heard around the world

After over two decades without getting a taste of the postseason, the Jays were suddenly contenders once again in 2015 when GM Alex Anthopoulos went “all-in” at the trade deadline. With key acquisitions in Cy Young winner David Price, along with star shortstop Troy Tulowitzki and leadoff hitter Ben Revere, it vaulted the team into the playoffs after spending most of the season hovering near the .500 mark.

In the ALDS, the Jays were up against the pesky Texas Rangers. Despite having both aces Price and Marcus Stroman lined up for the first two games in the series at home, Toronto somehow came out of it down 2-0 and facing elimination heading into Texas. The Jays would manage to get surprisingly strong starts from both Marco Estrada and R.A. Dickey to even up the series, bringing it back to Toronto for the fifth and series-deciding game.

Game 5 will certainly go down as perhaps one of the most exciting, controversial, yet intense games in Jays’ history. After the Rangers went ahead 3-2 in the top of the seventh inning on a bizarre toss back play by Jays’ catcher Russell Martin, a series of errors made by the Rangers in the bottom half of the inning help set up the hit heard around the world. With Jays’ slugger José Bautista at the plate, he delivered his biggest moment of his illustrious career by connecting on a go-ahead, three-run home run off Rangers’ reliever Sam Dyson. In doing so, his infamous bat flip became immortalized in baseball history. As a result, the Jays completed the huge series comeback from being down 2-0 to defeat the Rangers in five games.

However, the Jays would lose their playoff magic by the time they faced the Kansas City Royals in the ALCS. It would be a series filled with missed opportunities and misplays by Toronto, especially during the pivotal Game 6. With the game tied 3-3 in the eighth inning, Royals’ outfielder Lorenzo Cain managed to score all the way from first on an Eric Hosmer single when Bautista nonchalantly pursued the ball and threw it in casually to second base. 

Also in the ninth, the Jays managed to get a runner to third with nobody out thanks to two stolen bases by pinch-runner Dalton Pompey. Unfortunately, their star players would come up empty at the plate as the Jays lost the game 4-3 and the series 4-2 to the Royals, ending their spirited run.

2016 – The revenge on Odor and the Rangers

The Jays managed to make the postseason for the second consecutive season the following year in 2016. But for the first time in franchise history, the Jays had to take part in the one-game, winner-takes-all elimination AL Wild Card game against the Baltimore Orioles. The game was a close affair, as it remained tied at two from the fifth inning onwards. It ended up requiring extra innings to decide the match. It was then when Orioles’ manager Buck Showalter made the controversial call of using Ubaldo Jiménez instead of 2016 AL Reliever of the Year Zach Britton in the tight match. That move backfired big time as Edwin Encarnación went on to deliver the game-winning three-run homer in the bottom of the 11th inning to secure a 5-2 Jays win.

That put the Jays through to the ALDS in a rematch against their newly created rivals in the Rangers. The rivalry between the two teams started the previous season when the Jays made the improbable comeback to take the 2015 ALDS 3-2 from the Rangers. It quickly escalated during the 2016 season during a regular season game between the two clubs as a result of an aggressive slide by Bautista into second base. In doing so, Rangers’ second baseman Rougned Odor took exception of it and started a heated exchange with Bautista. In the process, Odor delivered a blow to Bautista’s face as the benches emptied.

Consequently, the drama helped build up the must-see playoff matchup between the two clubs. The Rangers were hoping for redemption from the previous season whereas the Jays were looking to exact some revenge for what they did to their star player. Bautista and the Jays sure got the last laugh when they ended up sweeping the Rangers handily in three games. The main highlight came in Game 3 in Toronto with the game tied at six heading into the bottom of the 10th inning. With Josh Donaldson on second with a leadoff double and Encarnación on first from an intentional walk, Martin hit a ground ball to Rangers’ shortstop Elvis Andrus. Andrus threw the ball to Odor covering second to get the out there. But when Odor transferred the ball to first in an attempt to complete the double play, the ball went way wide, allowing Donaldson to dash all the way home to seal the win for the Jays. 

Unfortunately, the Jays couldn’t carry that huge momentum that they gained from the ALDS into the ALCS against the Cleveland Indians at the time. In fact, their entire offense suffered a huge power outage as the Indians’ pitching staff, led by the infallible reliever Andrew Miller, held the Jays to just 2 home runs and 8 total runs over five games. As a result, the Indians took the series easily 4-1, ending the Jays’ last deep playoff run to date.

Hopefully, the Jays will be able to produce some more memorable postseason runs in the near future, but for this year, they can only sit back and wait for next season.