A look at how far the Toronto Blue Jays lineup has come since Opening Day 2018

Toronto Blue Jays v New York Yankees
Toronto Blue Jays v New York Yankees / Jim McIsaac/GettyImages
2 of 3
Next

Just five years ago, the Toronto Blue Jays were entering what would end up being the second of a three-year rebuild on the heels of two consecutive trips to the ALCS.

The 2018 Jays opened the season at home against the New York Yankees, losing 6-1 to start off a season that would see the club go 73-89, good for fourth place in the division.

Somewhat surprisingly, there is only one single player from that squad five years ago that remains on the team and that is catcher Danny Jansen. Every single other member of that year's active roster has moved on.

Let's compare the 2018 Opening Day starters with what will likely be the 2023 lineup and see just how far this club has come.

Catcher: Russell Martin (2018) Alejandro Kirk (2023)

Martin wound up playing four seasons in Toronto with 2018 being the last. The Canadian backstop played his entire career as a well-liked figure who left it all out on the field. He got into just 90 games in 2018, hitting 10 home runs and posting a .194 batting average.

Kirk, 24, came seemingly out of nowhere last season, making it to the All-Star Game as the starting catcher and eventually securing his first career Silver Slugger Award. He comes with his fair share of haters thanks to his unique body structure for a professional baseball player, but he has shown that he has the talent to not only succeed at the big league level, but excel.

First base: Justin Smoak (2018) Vladimir Guerrero Jr. (2023)

Smoak was a reliable, switch-hitting power hitter that gave the Blue Jays some much-needed thump in the middle of their lineup. He ended up playing five seasons in Toronto, hitting 117 home runs and even making it to the All-Star Game in 2017. He hit 25 home runs with a 122 OPS+ in 2018.

Vladdy is so dang young and has shown that he has what it takes to be a true superstar for the Jays. Still only 23-years-old, he has been one of the most consistent and fearsome hitters in the big leagues since his incredible breakout performance in 2021. Guerrero is a dynamic enough player that it wouldn't be at all surprising if he can somehow get even better than he was in '21.

Second base: Devon Travis (2018) Whit Merrifield (2023)

This 2018 campaign ended up being Travis' last in the big leagues. He played in Toronto for a total of four years and at times really showed some promise. However, he could not stay on the field and played just 316 of a total of 648 games. His intriguing blend of bat-to-ball skills and some solid defense at second base made him seem like a potential All-Star for the Jays but it never came together for Travis.

Merrifield, 34, came over from the Royals after being one of the better utilitymen in the game of baseball. He is entering his first full season in Toronto and is widely expected to nab the starting second base gig from Cavan Biggio and Santiago Espinal. Always a stolen base threat who is good for double-digit home runs and excellent defense all over the diamond, Merrifield is one of the more underrated players on this current squad.

Third base: Josh Donaldson (2018) Matt Chapman (2023)

After winning the AL MVP in 2015 and cementing his name in the Blue Jays record books, Donaldson sustained his MVP-caliber performance in each of 2016 and 2017 but began to fall back down to Earth a bit in 2018. He played in 36 games for the Jays that year, hitting five home runs with a .234 batting average before being traded to Cleveland.

Then there's Chapman, 29, who has shown time and time again that he is one of the best defensive third basemen of this generation. Chapman is entering his walk year and will be under some extra pressure to perform ahead of free agency. He is a lock to hit 25+ home runs and practically never allows balls past him at the hot corner.

Shortstop: Aledmys Díaz (2018) Bo Bichette (2023)

Díaz is a light-hitting utilityman who has bounced around the league a bit over his seven-year career in the bigs. 2018 is only the second 100+ game season for him in the majors and he performed admirably, hitting 18 home runs with a 105 OPS+ in 130 games. After a four-year stint in Houston, he just recently signed a free agent deal with the Oakland A's.

Bichette, 24, has his fair share of naysayers but is a real star-in-the-making for this Jays club. The AL leader in hits in each of the past two seasons, Bichette is a dynamic player at the plate and is seen as one of the core figures of this current Jays club. He will need to take some strides defensively in 2023 but past performance at shortstop has shown that the talent is there.

Left field: Curtis Granderson (2018) Daulton Varsho (2023)

The owner of one of the most exciting blends of power and speed in recent memory, Granderson joined the Blue Jays in 2018 near the end of his big league career. He played in 104 contests and hit 11 home runs with a 112 OPS+. While he was a shell of the player he once was by the time he became a Blue Jay, he had one heck of a big league career that spanned nearly two decades.

Varsho, 26, is going to suit up for a non-Diamondbacks team for the first time in his young career. He possesses an impressive mixture of power, speed and well above-average defense that should be more than enough to replace Lourdes Gurriel Jr. in left. Last season in Arizona, Varsho hit 27 home runs and drove in 74. Look for both of those numbers to go up in the newly-renovated Rogers Centre.

Center field: Kevin Pillar (2018) Kevin Kiermaier (2023)

Pillar began his career with the Blue Jays and was known as a human highlight reel. He was an annual lock to hit around 15 home runs but nearly all of his value was split between his ability to steal bases and play incredible defense in center. He is currently signed to a minor league contract with the Atlanta Braves for the upcoming campaign.

While Pillar put up an impressive 3.0 Defensive Runs Above Replacement in 2015, that mark was topped by the man who Toronto is going to turn to in center for 2023, Kevin Kiermaier. Kiermaier is another guy who isn't going to blow anyone away at the plate, but his defense is absolutely astounding when he's healthy. Health has been a concern for him over the past few seasons but he is reportedly healthy heading into 2023, so let's cross our fingers and toes that we can get a full season out of him.

Right field: Randal Grichuk (2018) George Springer (2023)

Grichuk spent three seasons as a member of the Blue Jays and was always a threat to hit a home run, hitting 25 in 2018, 31 in 2019 and 12 in the COVID-shortened 2020 campaign. He spent way more time in center than he should have with the Jays, since he is primarily a corner outfield option, but he was a well-liked figure during his time north of the border.

Then there's Springer, 33, who has also had his fair share of issues staying on the field. Last season, he played in 133 contests for the Jays, making his fourth All-Star Game and posting a 131 OPS+ on the year. 2023 is an important one for him as he is making the switch to right field full-time and will be a crucial part of this lineup.

Designated hitter: Kendrys Morales (2018) Brandon Belt (2023)

Morales had a profile so similar to then-teammate Justin Smoak's. Morales was a big switch-hitter who didn't have a spot on defense so spent the majority of his big league career as teams' designated hitter. With the Jays, he hit 49 home runs over two seasons and posted a combined .249 batting average and 103 OPS+.

Belt, 34, is leaving the Giants, the only organization he's ever known, to play in Toronto. He still has it at the plate, as evidenced by his 29 home runs in just 97 games in 2021 and is reportedly fully healthy heading into 2023. He can still swing the bat well and is a strong defender at first, so he will be able to competently fill in there whenever Vladdy needs a day off.

Next. Who is the most overpaid and underpaid Blue Jays player?. dark

Next