Brendon Little's been with the Toronto Blue Jays for about three seasons now and admittedly, it's been a roller coaster experience for the lefty. At times, he's shown he can be a high-leverage lefty reliever, but he's also shown how frustrating he can be.
Heading into 2027, Louis Varland, Tyler Rogers, Mason Fluharty, Braydon Fisher, and depending on his role, Spencer Miles are all guaranteed spots in the bullpen. That leaves at least one, and potentially two spots available in the bullpen.
Given Brendon Little's track record, should he be given a spot in the bullpen?
Why he should be in the bullpen
When Little's on top of his game, he's a dominant reliever. Little showed that dominance during the first half of 2025 where he posted a 2.03 ERA while striking out batters 34.8% of the time. At the time, Little was having a breakout season and he and Mason Fluharty formed a formidable 1-2 combination as John Schneider's lefties.
That's big-time from Brendon Little.
— Keegan Matheson (@KeeganMatheson) August 4, 2026
Four strikeouts, ending with Yordan Álvarez.
The #BlueJays are going to roll him out there a ton down the stretch to see what they have. Good start to it. pic.twitter.com/PiT7MReEg8
Little's shown the ability to improve and make adjustments. After being recalled in July, Little was able to finish the season strong posting a 2.28 ERA in 20.1 innings with an elite 37% strikeout rate. Although almost all of his innings were in low leverage situations, it's great to still see that when he's on, Little can be a solid reliever.
Why he shouldn't be guaranteed a spot
Although Little showed dominance in the first half of 2025, the wheels fell off in the second half. His ERA doubled to 4.88 and his strikeout rate dropped precipitously to 24.1%. He struggled to the point that he was used in low-medium leverage situations down the stretch, and including the postseason. He infamously gave up a grand slam to Cal Raleigh during Game 5 of the ALCS, and the walk off home run to Freddie Freeman in the 18th inning during Game 3 of the World Series.
Brendon Little has immediately given the lead back to the White Sox here in the 6th.
— Keegan Matheson (@KeeganMatheson) April 4, 2026
Brutal turn after Vladimir Guerrero Jr. finally broke the #BlueJays through in the top half. pic.twitter.com/zlgBDxL2gY
In 2026, despite a strong Spring Training, Little still looked like the 2025 second half version of himself. After struggling to the tune of a 24.55 ERA in 5 games, he was sent down to Buffalo to work on things. He made an appearance in late-June where allowed 4 earned runs in an inning of work and was sent back down after.
Despite an elite strike out ability, walks will always put a ceiling on how good Little can be. After he was recalled in July, his walk rate jumped even higher to 19%. Overall, if there's anything that the last two seasons have told us about Little, it's that his ceiling is a low-leverage reliever.
Little's out of options heading into 2027, and despite a strong second half in 2026, he shouldn't be guaranteed a spot. The free agent market is rich on left-handed relievers such as Adrian Morejon, Alex Vesia, and Steven Okert to name a few. The Blue Jays should go after a lefty and make Little earn his spot in the bullpen.
If he has a strong showing in Spring Training, the Blue Jays could opt to run with three lefties to start the season. If he's not able to carry that momentum forward, they shouldn't be afraid to expose him to waivers. Internally, there's Ricky Tiedemann and Brendan Cellucci on the 40-man roster and have options that could easily replace Little should they lose him to waivers.
