Louis Varland's Reliever of the Year destiny is being challenged by a crowded field

For much of the season, Louis Varland has been the runaway favorite for the American League Reliever of the Year Award. The first-time All-Star has been virtually untouchable for the Toronto Blue Jays all year long, recording a 1.30 ERA, 1.81 FIP, 31.7% strikeout rate, and 34 saves over 76 innings of work.

However, he's (relatively speaking) slowed down in the second half, logging a 1.67 ERA compared to his 1.10 mark prior to the All-Star break. He's still been ridiculous, but the door is now slightly ajar for other AL relievers to make a late season push.

So, is Varland still the favorite to win the award? Let's compare his numbers with the rest of a crowded field of elite relievers in the Junior Circuit.

Louis Varland's combination of volume and effectiveness remains unmatched among AL relievers

The easiest place to start is, as always, with WAR, and Varland's lead in that category is near-insurmountable. His 3.0 fWAR on the season easily paces all AL relievers, as only three others have even eclipsed the 2.0 mark.

Now, fWAR isn't a perfect stat, since it heavily factors things like inning volume which doesn't usually help a reliever's case. But even there, Varland has been a stud, pitching a whopping 76 innings that rank third among all AL relievers. Remember, this guy is a closer. The next-closest player with 10 or more saves is Cade Smith of the Guardians, who has thrown seven fewer innings than Varland.

For good measure, Varland also paces all of his AL bullpen mates in ERA, xERA, and FIP. It's difficult to express in words just how good he's been in 2026.

However, he's not perfect. A handful of relievers have better strikeout rates, and Bryan Baker of the Rays is cruising to a first-place finish in saves (40). It's not Varland's fault that Tampa Bay has won 17 more games than Toronto, but that saves total matters a lot to voters considering it's the defining stat for closers.

The conversation also becomes more difficult when you include non-qualified relievers like Josh Hader to the mix. He's appeared far less frequently than Varland this year, but his superior marks in ERA and FIP could matter to voters, especially since he's racked up 2.1 fWAR in just 42.1 innings this season.

Still, even with all of that competition swarming the race, it's hard not to like Varland's candidacy. He's married volume and effectiveness at an unparalleled level in 2026, putting together the only stat line in the league that rivals Mason Miller's work in San Diego. If the goal of giving out a "Reliever of the Year" award is to honor the best reliever regardless of circumstance, it's clear who should win the American League's trophy.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow