Davis Schneider’s Triple-A reset is already paying off for the Toronto Blue Jays

A stint in the minor leagues seems to have turned Davis Schneider’s season around for the second straight year—and that’s good news for the Toronto Blue Jays. 

Schneider starred in Tuesday night’s 6-1 victory over the Boston Red Sox (Jun. 16), hitting a home run and picking up another RBI on a double. It was his second straight game with a long ball after he also went deep in Sunday’s loss against the New York Yankees.

This tiny three-game sample since he’s returned is a reminder of how valuable Schneider can be when he’s clicking offensively. His presence is exactly what this Blue Jays lineup needs after months of underperformance. 

What’s changed for Schneider since he’s been recalled?

There were questions as to if or when Schneider would get back to the Blue Jays in 2026 after he was optioned to Triple-A Buffalo on May 25th amid an extended slump. 

Schneider posted a combined .454 OPS between April and May with just eight hits and zero home runs. He maintained a patient approach by walking 17 times in his 84 plate appearances, but also struck out 30 times in that sample size. 

These poor numbers were downright shocking on the heels of a season in which he recorded a .797 OPS (117 OPS+) with 11 home runs in just 227 plate appearances. He hit a leadoff home run in the World Series less than a year ago.

What is easy to forget is that Schneider was also demoted to Triple-A Buffalo in mid-April of 2025 after a slow start. Being sent down wasn’t a new experience for him—and the associated mental reset appears to have been exactly what the doctor ordered. 

Schneider’s plate appearances usually end in one of the three true outcomes: a walk, a home run, or a strikeout. Kyle Schwarber of the Philadelphia Phillies and Munetaka Murakami of the Chicago White Sox are prime examples of this divisive batting profile. 

Working a base on balls has never been an issue for Schneider, who has walked 18.2% of the time in 2026 despite his overall ineffectiveness at the plate. The strikeouts and lack of home runs have been his undoing thus far.

His 33.3% K-rate as of June 2026 is significantly worse than the already-high 26.4% mark he posted last season. It’s far more in line with his strikeout rate from 2024 during a nightmare sophomore season in which he hit just .191 after impressing as a rookie. 

The real key for Schneider, however, is pulling the ball as he did on Tuesday night when he ripped his home run into the Green Monster at Fenway Park. 

He stands five-foot-eight and weighs 190 pounds; he doesn’t have the raw power of Vladimir Guerrero Jr. or Aaron Judge. He needs to pull fly balls in the air to do damage, yet his pull rate dropped from roughly 59% in 2025 to 37.5% this year. Prioritizing getting the bat head out early when he swings is the key to getting back on track. 

Only time will tell if Schneider is really back, but a true re-emergence would be a fantastic development for a Blue Jays team desperate for right-handed offensive production.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow