Skip to main content

Current catching market further solidifies Alejandro Kirk’s team friendly deal

With Ryan Jeffers off the board and a thin crop of catchers behind him, the Blue Jays’ $11.6 million AAV for Kirk looks better than ever.
ByMatthew Sookram
Sep 12, 2026; Toronto, Ontario, CAN;  Toronto Blue Jays catcher Alejandro Kirk (30) takes to the field to play the Baltimore Orioles at Rogers Centre.  Mandatory Credit: Dan Hamilton-Imagn Images
Sep 12, 2026; Toronto, Ontario, CAN; Toronto Blue Jays catcher Alejandro Kirk (30) takes to the field to play the Baltimore Orioles at Rogers Centre. Mandatory Credit: Dan Hamilton-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The Toronto Blue Jays have plenty of work to do this offseason, but catcher is one position they don’t have to worry about. With Ryan Jeffers officially off the market and a thin class of free agent catchers behind him, the current landscape is a good reminder of just how team friendly the five-year, $58 million extension that Alejandro Kirk signed really is.

The deal runs from 2026 through 2030, buying out Kirk’s final year of arbitration and four free agent-eligible seasons, with a $6 million signing bonus and no deferred money. That works out to an average annual value of $11.6 million.

Kirk earned $8.7 million in 2026 ($7.5 million base salary plus $1.2 million in bonus proration) and is set to make $12.325 million in 2027 ($11.125 million base plus the same $1.2 million proration), before he becomes a free agent in 2031.

To see just how good the Blue Jays have it with Kirk, let's start with the price tag at the top of the market. Jeffers was widely viewed as the best catcher available, but instead of testing the market, he accepted Minnesota’s qualifying offer on Tuesday, which locks him in at $23.15 million for 2027. That is nearly double what Kirk is scheduled to earn next season, and about $11.55 million more than the AAV on Kirk’s contract.

Jeffers is a fine player, and the two had similar seasons in one respect. Each went down with an injury early on and bounced back afterwards. Jeffers was hitting .295/.408/.541 when a broken hamate bone ended his first half, and he finished at .256/.353/.461 with 14 home runs in 92 games.

Kirk fractured and dislocated his left thumb on a foul tip just days into the season and required surgery. Once he returned, he finished the year with a .278/.351/.415 line, 10 home runs and 43 RBI in 79 games, including a .341 August with five homers and 20 RBI. Even with the bat slightly favouring Jeffers, you’d have to lean toward Kirk when you factor in the gap in pay and the quality of his work behind the plate.

Blue Jays are glad they don't have to shop for a catcher this winter

The rest of the market doesn’t make the Blue Jays’ side of the comparison look any worse, either. MLB.com’s free agent breakdown has Carson Kelly, Tyler Stephenson, Austin Hedges and Kyle Higashioka rounding out the top of the class behind Jeffers.

Stephenson hit .241/.323/.404 with 15 home runs and a 99 wRC+ this season, while Kelly slashed .258/.336/.376 with 10 homers and a 103 wRC+. Both are projected to land short-term deals in the neighbourhood of $6 million to $12 million per year. Kirk’s .766 OPS beats both of them. With MLB Trade Rumors’ top 50 free agent list and the other rankings showing how little depth there is at the position, Toronto doesn’t have to get into a bidding war for catchers who produce less than the guy they already have inked in behind the dish.

It also helps that the Blue Jays have some flexibility. With Kirk secure behind the plate and rookie Brandon Valenzuela offering a strong glove and plenty of promise in the background, Toronto has a little extra room to explore other ways to fill holes on the roster.

But the real story here is that Kirk has become one of the steadiest players on the roster since he signed that deal. It was also a nice bit of business by general manager Ross Atkins. Locking Kirk in before he could hit the open market meant Toronto skipped the type of catching scramble that other clubs are now facing, and the current market only makes that price look better. When the best catcher available is going back to his old club for a one-year, $23.15 million payday, an $11.6 million AAV for a two-time All-Star who handles a pitching staff the way Kirk does looks like exactly what it is: a bargain.

Add us as a preferred source on Google