Everyone knows the 2026 Toronto Blue Jays failed on the weakness of their lineup. A combination of injuries and underperformance from key players ultimately led them to field baseball’s worst offence.
The front office is going to add a bat or two in free agency this winter. Vladimir Guerrero Jr. will most likely hit much better in 2027. However, one issue without a clear solution is how to get more offensive production from the shortstop position currently occupied by Andrés Giménez.
There’s no sugarcoating it: Giménez is not a good hitter. As such, the Blue Jays need to consider making a drastic change if they intend to compete next season.
What should the Blue Jays do with Andrés Giménez in 2027?
Giménez’s 2026 stat line left a lot to be desired. He slashed .241/.291/.359 with nine home runs and 59 RBIs. He also stole 20 bases in an efficient 24 attempts.
While his knack for delivering in the clutch is certainly commendable, Giménez just has too many empty at-bats. A sub-.300 on base percentage is simply unacceptable—he walked just 17 times in 148 games. His undisciplined approach is untenable.
His underlying metrics also aren’t encouraging; his Baseball Savant page is bluer than his jersey. He chases outside the zone 43.9% of the time, which ranks in the 2nd percentile. His 24.9% hard-hit rate, meanwhile, is among the worst in the sport. So is his 68.3 mph bat speed.
The Blue Jays need to accept that the version of Giménez that posted a .837 OPS in 2022 doesn’t exist anymore. The one who was a roughly league-average hitter in 2023 probably doesn’t exist anymore, either. Whatever hope they had of him returning to that level when they acquired him has been unequivocally snuffed out over the past two seasons.
So what can they do? The fact Giménez is owed roughly $23.5 million for each of the next three seasons makes things tricky. It’s hard to see general manager Ross Atkin’s decision to take on this contract as anything other than an unforced error.
The first thing the Blue Jays need to do is remember that they are a big market team. One of the privileges of having financial resources is not needing to play underperforming players just because they make a lot of money—this logic also applies to Anthony Santander.
Is there anyone who would take Giménez off their hands? Probably not at this salary, unless they’re willing to take back another bad contract in return. Perhaps the Texas Rangers would be willing to do it in a deal that allows them to unload Corey Seager’s albatross of a deal.
There isn’t a star shortstop on the open market this winter, meaning the Blue Jays would probably need to acquire one via the trade market. Jeremy Peña would be a great fit if the Houston Astros are willing to move him. The same could be said about Gunnar Henderson.
Toronto signing a second baseman this winter appears much more likely with Jazz Chisholm Jr. and Brandon Lowe both available. Adding one of these guys could allow them to at least platoon Giménez with Ernie Clement, with the hope of getting better production out of both by playing the matchup game based on handedness.
Ultimately, the Blue Jays need to do something because Giménez simply isn’t cutting it. Great defense and solid baserunning isn’t enough when your bat is this poor. The plan for the shortstop position needs to be different come Opening Day in 2027.
