Skip to main content

Blue Jays have decisions to make with pitching prospect depth

Should they look to keep them or move some of them?
ByDavid Cho
Johnny King, a pitcher for the Dunedin Blue Jays warms up in the bullpen before a game against the Fort Myers Mighty Mussels at Hammond Stadium on Saturday, Aug. 2, 2025. King is a Naples High School alum and two time baseball player of the year.
Johnny King, a pitcher for the Dunedin Blue Jays warms up in the bullpen before a game against the Fort Myers Mighty Mussels at Hammond Stadium on Saturday, Aug. 2, 2025. King is a Naples High School alum and two time baseball player of the year. | USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect

FanGraphs recently released their top 38 prospects for the Toronto Blue Jays, and the overall feedback of the Blue Jays system was that "pitching is clearly the strength." With several holes to fill on the main roster the Blue Jays front office could look at dealing from this depth to make sure the team can compete again in 2027.

The problem though is answering the question, "who should they keep and who is expendable." It's extremely hard to project a young players true trajectory, especially with pitchers being so volatile year to year and susceptible to injury. Front offices are also leary of making any moves that could come back to bite them if the return becomes underwhelming.

Seven pitchers are in the top 10 of the Blue Jays' list. Johnny King headlines the list as he made he made it Double-A. At only 20-years-old, he held his own after the promotion. His rotation mate, Nolan Perry was No. 2 on the list and was recently added to the 40-man roster. If there's no baseball next season, Perry and King will still get reps in the minors with the goal of having them compete for a roster spot in 2028.

A couple of names to primarily keep tabs on next year are Cole Carlon and Dasan Hill. Carlon hasn't debuted yet in an effort to preserve his workload and prepare him as a starter for 2027. Hill was acquired from the Twins in the Jeff Hoffman trade and looked much better coming over. Both lefties have the stuff and velocity, but their command will ultimately decide their long-term role.

Other names to keep eyes on are: Daniel Guerra, Gage Stanifer, and Jhon Rivas. Guerra was recently added to the 40-man roster and deservedly so after pitching at all five levels (Rookie and Low-A were for rehab purposes).

Stanifer wasn't able to build on his 2025 breakout as he struggled greatly with command, and surprisingly wasn't protected from the Rule 5 draft. Rivas pitched to a 1.62 ERA in the FCL and already sits in the mid-90s with his fastball.

What should the Blue Jays do with their pitching prospects?

While the Blue Jays have some hitting prospects to be excited about, most notably JoJo Parker and Will Brick, the quality of the bats fall off rapidly after those two. In comparison, the quality of the pitching doesn't fall off as quick. They have serviceable arms at each level which helps them in the event of an injury.

The Blue Jays knows their developmental strength and should continue to lean on it. There's a saying in prospect circles called "TINSTAAPP," (There Is No Such Thing As A Pitching Prospect), and the Blue Jays should deal from their pitching depth, especially with how often they can get injured and the variances in their performance year over year.

The Blue Jays need another starter to fill out the rotation, and are firmly entrenched in the Tarik Skubal sweepstakes. Their other priorities includes second base and left field, and they can leverage their pitching prospects in those trades, whether that is a trade for Ketel Marte, or others.

Add us as a preferred source on Google