It wasn’t too long ago when the Toronto Blue Jays were loaded with catching depth. There was a time when the Blue Jays had a real choice to make between Gabriel Moreno, Danny Jansen and Alejandro Kirk.
However, Moreno, the Blue Jays’ No. 1 prospect at the time, was dealt in the infamous trade with the Arizona Diamondbacks to get Daulton Varsho. Jansen was later traded at the 2024 deadline to the Boston Red Sox. That catching depth grew thin really quickly. As a result, the Blue Jays made catching one of their key priorities in subsequent drafts, trades and international free agent signings.
That determined effort by Toronto appears to be paying off. At the 2025 trade deadline the Blue Jays targeted Brandon Valenzuela, dealing Will Wagner to the San Diego Padres in exchange. That move paid huge dividends in the first half of the 2026 season after Kirk went down to injury and Tyler Heineman struggled, before his eventual release.
And, as Fangraphs pointed out in their latest prospect rankings, catching is becoming one of the strengths of the organization again. There could be a logjam brewing in due time. Among the Jays’ Top 20 prospects, Fangraphs has four catchers. Will Brick is found at No. 7, while Juan Caricote sits right behind him in No. 8. Ryan Sprock occupies the No. 18 position, while Franklin Rojas rounds things out at No. 19 on the list.
Blue Jays have four catchers among their top 20 prospects in the organization according to Fangraphs
Having Brick at No. 7 shows the lofty expectations that the Blue Jays have out of their fourth round pick from the 2026 MLB Draft. Selected right out of Christian Brothers High School in Memphis, Tennessee, the 18-year-old catcher is projected to fill out to a score of 50-55 for power and 55 for hitting once fully matures. His defense will be a work in progress. Brick has yet to begin pro ball with the Blue Jays and is expected to start in the Florida Complex League next spring.
Caricote was the Blue Jays’ top player selected from the 2026 international free agent class. He was signed to a $1.9 million deal. Unlike Brick, Caricote has already made his debut in the Dominican Summer League, where he batted .274 with an .802 OPS, along with 23 runs scored, seven doubles, two triples, five home runs and 38 RBIs in 52 games with the DSL Blue Jays. He may still be years away from reaching the majors, but Fangraphs views him highly and projects him as an everyday catcher once he arrives.
Sprock was originally drafted by the Minnesota Twins in the eighth round back in the 2025 MLB Draft. The 22-year-old catcher joined the Blue Jays before the 2026 trade deadline after he was acquired from the Twins for reliever Tommy Nance and international signing bonus pool space.
In 31 games with High-A Vancouver, Sprock compiled a strong .307 average and a .963 OPS, with 27 runs scored, eight doubles, six home runs and 20 RBIs. He also showed solid plate discipline with 20 walks and just 24 strikeouts over 139 plate appearances. He is the furthest along of the four and should reach the majors and make an impact the soonest if all goes as planned.
Finally, Rojas was signed as an international free agent out of Venezuela by the Blue Jays in 2024, receiving a $1.1 million signing bonus. The 19-year-old prospect played in the Rookie League with the FCL Blue Jays in 2026.
He registered a solid .266/.413/.427 slash line with an .840 OPS slash line. He added 26 runs scored, 12 doubles, three home runs and 29 RBIs in 44 games played. His glove is definitely more of his strength, but if he can round things out with some consistent hitting and built-up power, Rojas could have everyday upside as Fangraphs projected.
The young catching depth that the Blue Jays now possess makes their future look bright as they follow in the footsteps of Blue Jays catching general Alejandro Kirk and the motivated rookie Valenzuela.
