Blue Jays' elimination from playoff contention is only made worse by bullpen's heroic efforts

With their loss in the first half of Wednesday's doubleheader against the Baltimore Orioles, the Toronto Blue Jays were officially eliminated from postseason contention. It confirms the fall from grace following their pennant-winning campaign a year ago, mercifully ending a season besieged by injuries and underperformances on every corner of the roster.

Not everyone deserves the same sized slice of the blame pie. While the offense continued to scuffle and the rotation merely tried to survive an endless onslaught of injuries, the Blue Jays' bullpen did their best to pick up the slack down the stretch. Since the trade deadline, that unit ranks sixth in the league in ERA (3.37) and second in innings pitched (200.1).

Even with so many great individual performances down the stretch, it wasn't enough. Now, the Blue Jays must live with the fact that they wasted an opportunity to go on a postseason run with an elite bullpen.

Celebrating Blue Jays bullpen stars who tried their best to get the team to October

This won't be a fun exercise following elimination, but it's worth celebrating the relievers who dominated while the Jays were fighting for their lives. The biggest standout was absolutely Spencer Miles, who evolved from a Rule 5 pick into a high-leverage option for John Schneider in the matter of one season. He compiled a 1.23 ERA and 2.08 FIP after the trade deadline, locking down two saves in 13 appearances.

All-Star closer Louis Varland deserves a shout-out as well, as he continued his march toward the AL Relief Pitcher of the Year award with a bullpen-leading 0.6 fWAR and 1.77 ERA after Aug. 3. He also added 10 more saves to his ledger to give him 34 on the year, cementing his 2026 campaign as one of the best seasons by a Blue Jays closer in recent memory.

Other post-deadline stars include waiver claim Paul Seawald (0.73 ERA in 15 appearances), Mason Fluharty (1.08 ERA in 22 appearances), Braydon Fisher (1.47 ERA in 20 appearances), Tyler Rogers (2.14 ERA in 22 appearances), and Brendon Little (2.30 ERA in 18 appearances). Alongside Varland and Miles, that's seven relievers who posted a 2.30 ERA or better over the final two months of the season. Like I said, this has been a wasted opportunity.

Now, some of those results were the product of good fortune -- the bullpen as a whole ranked 20th in FIP (4.29) -- but that's just further proof that Toronto really should have taken advantage of this excellent stretch from the relief corps.

If there is a positive takeaway here, it's that six of those seven relievers above (not including Seawald) are under contract next season. If nothing else, that gives the Blue Jays at least one aspect of the roster to build off of this upcoming offseason.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow