Blue Jays already getting proof their surprising trade deadline plan had merit

The Toronto Blue Jays were busy at the deadline. They did a little bit of buying and selling. The Blue Jays traded players with expiring contracts, such as Kevin Gausman and Daulton Varsho, while adding controllable pieces, such as José Soriano.

While the Blue Jays' mix of buying and selling was a little bit unexpected, the early returns would suggest it worked well for them. Rosternomics named the Blue Jays as one of the big winners from the trade deadline from a value model stand point.

It's been over a week since the deadline passed, and Blue Jays fans have gotten a look at some of the team's new additions. Soriano made his first start with the team against the Philadelphia Phillies. He pitched 4.2 innings, while giving up one earned run on four hits. He had another strong outing in his second start with the Blue Jays and his first at home earlier this week. He gave up one run on four hits in six innings.

Soriano was the first sign they Blue Jays weren't just planning on selling. The move came the morning after Gausman was traded to the Chicago Cubs since he is under team control until the end of the 2028 season. He had an amazing start to the year that saw him named the American League Pitcher of the Month for April. Soriano has come back down to Earth a bit since then, posting a 3.16 ERA for the season. But as a replacement for Gausman, Soriano is a great addition to the Blue Jays, and he has a high ceiling which the Blue Jays are hoping he can reach as he continues to develop.

Speaking of Gausman, Blue Jays fans have gotten a look at one of the players they got from the Cubs in that trade. Brett Bateman made his MLB debut with the Blue Jays on Aug. 7 against the Phillies. He hit a double off the first pitch he saw from Zach Wheeler in his first at-bat.

In Bateman's first six games with the Blue Jays, he's had hits in all but one, including two multi-hit games. He's shown good defence in centre field, displaying his highly rated speed, which is an area where the Blue Jays have been lacking. The Blue Jays rank 28th in sprint speed, while Bateman is second to Myles Straw among the Blue Jays in that category.

The Blue Jays also acquired RHP Jameson Taillon from the Cubs after he was designated for assignment. Taillon made two starts with the Blue Jays, but had to leave his second start after throwing four scoreless innings due to right forearm discomfort. Taillon was later placed on the 15-day IL with right forearm tendinitis.

The only other deadline acquisition the Blue Jays have gotten a look at is Josh Smith, whom they acquired from the Texas Rangers, along with RHP Josh Stephan, for LHP Adam Macko. He hasn't been overly impressive in his eight games with the Blue Jays, slashing .235/.316/.412. However, he did have a three-hit game against the Phillies with a home run.

The Blue Jays also acquired RHP Spencer Arrighetti from the Houston Astros in exchange for Daulton Varsho. Arrighetti is currently on the IL with Morton's neuroma in his right foot, so he hasn't yet made an appearance with the team. Like Soriano, Arrighetti is capable of being a very effective starter for the Blue Jays. He was the AL Pitcher of the Month for May, during which he posted a 0.93 ERA. He's struggled more otherwise in 2026, posting a 4.60 ERA in 17 starts.

Also like Soriano, Arrighetti is under team control for years to come. The Blue Jays managed to trade the expiring contract of Varsho for a player who is under team control until the end of the 2029 season.

Blue Jays contract surplus is what gives them the edge in their deadline deals

The early returns from the Blue Jays' trade deadline acquisitions have been positive, but the best may be yet to come. Four of the prospects the Blue Jays acquired are now ranked in their top 30, including Bateman who is ranked 20th.

While it wasn't the deadline strategy the Blue Jays were probably hoping for off the back of their World Series appearance in 2025, they managed to set themselves up for success in the future, while still giving themselves a chance to compete in 2026. They moved several expiring contracts, while also getting rid of one that expires after next season (Hoffman). Every player they received will be in a Blue Jays uniform until at least 2028.

Time will tell how well the 2026 trade deadline will age for the Blue Jays, but in terms of assets moved versus assets gained, the Blue Jays have already come out ahead.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow