Blue Jays have options to cover a Teoscar Hernandez absence

It looks like Teoscar Hernandez could be headed to the Injured List, unless his MRI comes back clean. How will the Blue Jays cover for his absence?

First of all, it’s pretty much impossible to just replace a hitter of Hernandez’s calibre, who has won back to back Silver Slugger awards in the American League. Any way you slice it, the potential for missed time from the 29 year old is a big blow, so hopefully it won’t be an extended absence. That said, it was very clear that he was in pain as he left the field on Wednesday night, and while I’m not a doctor, I’m pretty confident that he’s dealing with some sort of oblique issue. Unfortunately obliques can be complicated, and he could be on the shelf for a while.

In the meantime the Blue Jays are going to have to make due without him, and they do have a few options to fill his spot. Thanks to some roster flexibility the Jays have a few different options, and I imagine they’ll distribute the playing time between a few different players. Unfortunately they’re also dealing with an injury to Danny Jansen, and what looked like a deep roster is starting to show some holes. Sometimes that just can’t be helped, and in the case of the catching position it looks like the Blue Jays will roll with Alejandro Kirk as their main starter, with Zack Collins and Tyler Heineman serving in a back-up role.

As for right field, here are just a few ways the Blue Jays could make due until their All-Star slugger can return.

A roll of the dice with upside

Last week the Blue Jays made a smaller trade that caught me by surprise. I didn’t expect them to have much interest in Bradley Zimmer, but it made sense since they were able to pick him up for depth bullpen arm in Anthony Castro.

Zimmer was once a highly touted prospect with 5-tool potential, but his career hasn’t worked out that way so far. He has struggled to adjust to the big leagues throughout his time with the Cleveland Guardians, and really hasn’t lived up to the first round billing at all. He was having a disastrous spring, and even the outfielder-needy Guardians couldn’t justify keeping him around (this was before Steven Kwan’s fantastic opening week).

When they first acquired him I really didn’t see a role for him in Toronto, but if Hernandez does end up missing significant time on the IL, maybe this is the chance that Zimmer needs to get his big league career back on track. He has a reputation as a quality defender up the middle, he comes with a left-handed hat that helps as long as he’s producing, and right now the Blue Jays look pretty smart for picking him up on the cheap.

If I’m being honest, I don’t know that I have very high expectations for a turnaround, but there’s enough reason to like the roll of the dice. As I already mentioned, I expect that Tapia will become more of a full-time player now, but they’re going to need a fourth outfielder and Zimmer just moved up the depth chart. With the occasional need for a half day’s rest for George Springer while he serves as the DH, and with Jansen already on the shelf (which pushes Kirk into more games as the catcher), there is going to be playing time available for those that produce.

Still just 29 years old, perhaps this is the fresh start that Zimmer needed.

Shuffling the lineup

If the Blue Jays want to utilize the versatility of their roster to help cover for Teoscar Hernandez’s injury, they could break up the quasi-platoon they’ve been using at second base.

It remains to be seen if Cavan Biggio can bounce back from his injury-riddled and disappointing 2021 season, but I’d be more than happy to see him playing close to every day and getting the chance to turn things around. The biggest obstacle in the way for him this week has been the solid play from Santiago Espinal, who feels like he’s gaining a grip on the job at second base. If Hernandez is out for an extended period of time, the Blue Jays could always look at moving Biggio to the outfield on a more regular basis.

It’s not an ideal solution for the 27 year old, as I think most of us can agree that it would be better if he could stick to one spot (ideally second base) and focus on finding his groove again, but there could be a silver lining to Hernandez’s injury, at least for Biggio. It might be a path to regular playing time, which was a door that was starting to look like it was closing.

The downside to this idea is that all three of Tapia, Zimmer, and Biggio hit from the left side, so it’s unfortunate the Blue Jays don’t have more of a compliment to the roster for the days they’re facing a left-hander. That said, hopefully Hernandez’s injury won’t keep him on the sidelines for an extended period. If that’s the case, they can live with giving Biggio and Tapia more at-bats against southpaws.

For now, it’s a game of wait and see as far as how severe Hernandez’s injury will be, and just how much time he’ll miss. With any luck, the Blue Jays will only need a short-term solution.