Opposing pitchers on the wrong side of Blue Jays history

Looking back at the history of the Blue Jays franchise, numerous instances stick out for fans of all different ages and fandoms. The Jose Bautista bat flip, the Edwin Encarnacion Wild Card walk off, and of course, the Joe Carter World Series clincher.

There have been numerous big moments in Blue Jays history when it comes to players stepping up at the plate, but what about the pitchers who gave up those miraculous moments?

Charlie Leibrandt – Game Six, 1992 World Series

The franchise won their first-ever World Series in 1992 and did so against Atlanta Braves left-hander Charlie Leibrandt in extra innings in Game #6 of the 1992 World Series.

The veteran left-hander produced a clean tenth inning but was unable to keep runs off the scoreboard in the 11th. Leibrandt hit Devon White and gave up a single to Roberto Alomar before Dave Winfield, with two outs already on the board, produced a groundball down the left-field line that scored both White and Alomar, putting the Jays up by two in the top half of the inning.

The Jays pitching corps gave up one run in the 11th but after an Otis Nixon bunt and the subsequent throw from pitcher Mike Timlin to first, the World Series trophy was making its way North of the border for the first time in baseball history.

Leibrandt would earn the loss in that game and would only pitch one more season in the big leagues, finishing the 1993 season with the Texas Rangers before retiring. For his career, the southpaw amassed a 3.71 ERA through 394 outings (346 starts) with four different organizations, posting a 1.320 WHIP and a 4.4 K/9 rate through 2308.0 innings of work.

Ubaldo Jimenez – AL Wild Card 2016

In an exciting back and forth game during the 2016 AL Wild Card, the Blue Jays were trying to put together another playoff run after the “all in” 2015 season but were now under new management in general manager Ross Atkins and President/CEO Mark Shapiro.

At the Rogers Centre, the Blue Jays hosted the Baltimore Orioles in a game that required extra innings under the dome, with each team heading into free baseball territory with two runs apiece. All was silent until the 11th inning, with Orioles pitcher Brian Duensing leading off the inning. He retired outfielder Ezequiel Carrera and was replaced with veteran Ubaldo Jimenez, with the right-hander giving up back-to-back singles before leaving a fastball over the plate for slugger Edwin Encarnacion, who promptly sent a no-doubter over the left-field wall and sent the Jays into the ALCS for a second consecutive season.

The biggest controversy out of this game was that Zach Britton, the Orioles closer, was kept on the sidelines even with the playoffs on the line. The Blue Jays didn’t complain, as Encarnacion played the hero and trotted around the bases with his signature right arm in the air for all to see.

After the Wild Card game, Jimenez spent one more season with Baltimore, posting 6.81 ERA through 31 appearances and never appeared in a Major League game after the 2017 campaign. He attempted a comeback in 2020 with the Colorado Rockies on a MiLB deal but was released by the club in mid-July and retired shortly after.

For his career, Jimenez finished with a 4.34 ERA through 329 outings, with the best years of his career coming with the Colorado Rockies in the mid-2000s. He made one All-Star appearance in 2010 and finished third in Cy Young voting that season.

Mitch Williams – Game Six World Series 1992

With the Blue Jays entering their second World Series in as many years, the club was facing a tough Philadelphia Phillies team that boasted a very strong pitching corps along with a solid batting order.

The series ultimately went to six games and came down the wire once again, with the Blue Jays entering Game Six with a chance to win it all in front of a home crowd (unlike the year prior). While this game did not go to extra innings like in 1992, it surely came down to the wire in the ninth inning, where the Jays batting order was able to put some runners in scoring position before Joe Carter hit one of the biggest home runs in franchise history.

Some of the biggest moments in Blue Jays history have come in extra innings or off a walk-off home run. Whatever happened to the opposing pitchers?

Phillies closer Mitch ‘Wild Thing’ Williams came into the ninth inning with a narrow 6-5 lead. The right-hander walked Rickey Henderson before getting Devon White to pop-up but allowed Paul Molitor to get on base with a single, putting runners on first and second. Carter was next to bat amongst the WAMCO lineup and put the ball over the left-field wall, scoring three runs and making the Blue Jays back-to-back World Series champions.

After the 1993 season, Williams struggled at the Major League level, sporting 7.65 and 6.75 ERA’s the following seasons with the Houston Astros (the Phillies traded him after the 1993 World Series) and California Angels respectively. His last season was in 1997 with the Kansas City Royals, where he appeared in only seven games and allowed eight earned runs through 6.2 innings.

Matt Bush – Game 3 ALDS 2016

Meeting once again in the ALDS for a second consecutive postseason, the Toronto Blue Jays and Texas Rangers were not on good terms heading into this matchup. After the Bautista bat-flip and the bench-clearing brawl during the regular season, these two teams were meeting in the ALDS once again but with a bit of bad blood.

The Jays took a quick 2-0 lead in the series and were looking to finish off the Rangers at home. The game had a bit of a back and forth feel to it, with both clubs producing runs early and was tied at 6-6 after nine innings. Extras were needed and while the 10th inning produced nothing exciting, the Jays were able to put some runners in scoring position in the 11th to make things interesting.

On the bump was right-hander Matt Bush, who was entering the 11th on the heels of his third-inning out of the bullpen. Josh Donaldson started it off with a leadoff double which led to Bush intentionally walking Edwin Encarnacion to put runners on first and second. Jose Bautista struck out to put one out on the board with catcher Russell Martin up next. Martin hit a ground ball to shortstop and while Rougned Odor was able to get the out at second, his errant throw to first caused Mitch Moreland to come off the bag at first base. Donaldson continued on and was able to score in dramatic fashion at home plate, with Moreland’s throw short hopping the catcher. Rangers manager Jeff Banister threw a hail mary review call out but umpire Joe West, making one of the better translations for the decision made in New York, called Donaldson safe at home and the series was over.

While Odor is the main reason the Rangers lost the game because of his errant throw, Bush walked away with the loss. The Rangers right-hander was actually part of the Jays organization back in 2009 but never appeared in a Major League game, with the club releasing him roughly two months after being traded to Toronto due to off-the-field issues. He signed with the Tampa Bay Rays in 2010 and was in their organization until 2012 before being arrested for drunk driving and running over a man behind the wheel, eventually serving time behind bars.

After being released, Bush joined the Rangers two months later in late 2015 and spent the next three seasons with the club before undergoing two Tommy John surgeries in 2018 and 2019. He most recently pitched with Texas last season, posting a 6.75 ERA through four outings with the club. Bush is currently a free agent.

Sam Dyson – Game 5 ALDS 2015

Continuing on with the Texas Rangers/Toronto Blue Jays theme, we head back to 2015 where Jose Bautista angered every fan of the ‘unwritten rules’ with his monster bat flip.

After a tough series that saw the Blue Jays force Game 5 back in Toronto, the seventh inning of this game will enter franchise folklore as one of the most entertaining innings in the history of the Jays organization.

A Russell Martin throwing error off the bat of Shin-Soo Choo scored Rougned Odor from third, which led to manager John Gibbons playing the game under protest and Blue Jays fans throwing beer cans onto the field. All that would be forgotten in the bottom half of the inning however, as numerous fielding errors by Elvis Andrus and the Rangers as well as controversial play at home involving a sneaky Dalton Pompey slide led to a Jays comeback in dramatic fashion.

On the mound was former Blue Jays draft pick Sam Dyson, who was taking over for veteran starter Cole Hamels. He gave up a bloop hit to Donaldson, mostly because Odor forgot how to play second base, and the tying run scored while getting the out at second. Up stepped Bautista with runners on third and first and two outs, with the Dominican product hammering a 1-1 inside fastball into the Blue Jays bleachers, giving the club the lead and eventually sending them to the ALCS.

For Dyson, he enters Blue Jays history as being the pitcher who gave up the Jose Bautista bat flip home run. Following the 2015 season, the right-hander spent one and a half seasons with the Rangers before being traded to the San Francisco Giants midway through the 2017 campaign. He spent two seasons in the Bay Area before being traded to the Minnesota Twins in 2019, finishing the year there before becoming a free agent.

Dyson has not appeared in a Major League game since 2019 following an investigation by the MLB that resulted in him being suspended for the entire 2021 campaign due to domestic violence allegations/violations. He is currently a free agent and will most likely never appear in the Major Leagues ever again.

For his career, the right-hander has amassed a 3.40 ERA through 376 appearances with 310 strikeouts and a home run that will be told to generations of Blue Jays fans.