Blue Jays: A 20-year review of the top-ranked organizational prospects

2005 – Brandon League
Brandon League was drafted by the Blue Jays in the 2001 amateur draft in the 2nd round (59th overall). League was ranked as the 69th best prospect on the top 100 list. League was a failed starter turned bullpen arm. He never started an MLB game. As a reliever, he did manage a 12 yr career split between 3 different teams. His most success came as a member of the Seattle Mariners where he would produce one all-star season with 37 saves as their closer.
Hindsight Alternates-. Aaron Hill 1x all-star, 2x silver slugger
Who did they miss in the draft – Ryan Howard was drafted in the 5th round. 3x all-star, 1x MVP,
2007 – Adam Lind
Adam Lind was selected by the Jays in the 3rd round of the 2005 amateur entry draft (83 overall). Lind had been ranked as the 39th best prospect on top 100 lists. He was never an all-star but did produce one silver slugger award over his 12 yr career (9 with the Jays).
Hindsight Alternates- The farm was pretty thin so the options were limited
Who did they miss in the draft – Ben Zobrist was drafted in the 6th round. 3x all-star, 2x world series winner, 1x world series MVP
2008 & 2009 – Travis Snider
Travis Snider was drafted by the Blue Jays in the 2006 amateur entry draft in the 1st round ( 14th overall). Travis was ranked as the 11th and 6th best prospect on top 100 lists. Travis has played in parts of 10 MLB seasons with 3 different organizations and is currently attempting a comeback with the Diamondbacks. He always had a high strikeout rate and just hasn’t managed to stick.
Hindsight Alternates- Again the farm was pretty barren. I could throw out Brett Cecil who has had a 10 yr career and 1x all-star.
Who did they miss in the draft –Dellin Betances was selected in the 8th round. 4x all-star and 621 career strikeouts in only 381.2 innings.