Blue Jays: Who is competing to make the team this spring?

The Outfield

As mentioned on the last page, the Blue Jays addressed their outfield needs by signing Curtis Granderson to a one year, five million dollar deal, and by trading for Randal Grichuk. The latter is expectedt to be an everyday starter in right field, while Granderson will likely platoon with Steve Pearce in left. Add Kevin Pillar in centre field, and you’ve pretty much got the picture of who will be on the field.

The biggest question in the outfield mix is whether or not the Blue Jays will find a way to keep Ezequiel Carrera around, who has been with the team for the last three seasons. While he’s been an underrated performer in the past, he’s likely at least a bit redundant now. He’s not terribly gifted defensively either, so after the additions of Grichuk and Granderson, his fit with the team going forward is a serious question.

That said, he’s been a favourite of John Gibbons for awhile now, and it wouldn’t be surprising if they found a way to keep him around, at least to start the season. His playing time will be pretty limited either way, so it wouldn’t be surprising to see him traded to another team with an outfield need either.

There’s also the group consisting of talented youngsters like Teoscar Hernandez, Anthony Alford, Dalton Pompey and more. Hernandez in particular looks like he’s ready to make the jump to the highest level, but he’ll likely have to wait until the injury bug bites one of the veterans in order to get a shot. His performance in September was certainly encouraging though, and it’s nice to have someone like him available if injury does strike. Alford could probably use a little more seasoning before being fully ready for the big leagues, and Pompey will need to prove he can stay healthy and that he still has the promise he showed a few years back.

Chances are we’ll see an outfield mix of Pillar, Grichuk, Granderson, Pearce, and maybe Carrera to start the 2018 season, but don’t be surprised if there are little tweaks made either before the season, or some time during the campaign.

Back-up Catcher

This is one area of the roster that I’m surprised that Ross Atkins and company didn’t address this offseason, but it could also be an area they’re still keeping a close eye on. As things stand right now, Luke Maile would be the favourite for the job after playing in 46 games for the Blue Jays last year.

He missed a good chunk of time recovering from knee surgery, but even while playing through pain he was the Blue Jays’ best option last season, despite hitting just .146/.176/.243. Among the group that included Miguel Montero, Jarrod Saltalamacchia, Raffy Lopez, and Mike Ohlman, the Blue Jays weren’t able to find a solution behind the plate when Russell Martin needed a day off, or when he had to spend time on the disabled list. Maile at least provided above average defence when he was in the lineup, something that he others had a hard time bringing to the table in addition to their struggles in the batter’s box.

The hope is that Maile can hit a little better now that his knee is fully healthy, and also that Martin will have a healthier year than 2017, when he was only able to play 91 games. I wouldn’t be surprised if Atkins and Mark Shapiro were watching rival clubs to see if other options become available, and also if they’re keeping a close eye on their own prospects like Reese McGuire and Danny Jansen. It’s likely that those two start the year in the minor leagues where they’ll receive more regular playing time, but the Blue Jays are better equipped in the upper levels, at least compared to the position they found themselves in last year.

The Infield

Assuming everyone is healthy, and that’s admittedly a very big “IF”, the Blue Jays infield picture is pretty well taken care of. Josh Donaldson and Justin Smoak return at the corners, Russell Martin will handle the majority of the catching duties, and the Jays will hope that Troy Tulowitzki and Devon Travis can have healthier seasons than they did in 2017, when they combined to play just 116 games.

The infield depth is arguably the biggest area of change this offseason, and it was a need that Atkins and Shapiro identified and addressed early this winter. The addition of the versatile Yangervis Solarte gives the Blue Jays another starting calibre infielder with experience all over the diamond. A fan favourite of the Padres, I’m confident that Blue Jays’ fans will grow to appreciate him in very short order. There’s also the addition of Aledmys Diaz, who not only shores up the shortstop position considerably, but he’s also a worthwhile gamble with a lot of upside, especially after hitting .300 with 17 home runs as a rookie.

As I said above, the infield health situation is a big if, and it’s already evidenced by Troy Tulowitzki’s delayed start dealing with bone spur issues. If he or anyone else can’t go on Opening Day, there are options like Gift Ngoepe, Richard Urena, and more that could handle duties up the middle if needed as well.

When it comes to the infield equation, the biggest question may be whether or not Diaz makes the Opening Day roster. If the Blue Jays do decide to hang on to all five outfielders including Ezequiel Carrera, it’s going to be hard to find room for Diaz as well. Of course, that’ll hinge on whether Tulowitzki can be fully healthy, and whether everyone else can get through camp without getting hurt.

Bullpen

*Note- After this article had been written, the Blue Jays have reportedly signed Seung-hwan Oh to a one year, two million dollar deal with a vesting option for 2019. The deal was first reported by Robert Murray of FanRagSports, and is pending a physical. 

The bullpen is the biggest question for me at this stage of the Grapefruit schedule, and that’s a common thing at this time of year. Again barring injury, we know that the group will include Roberto Osuna, Ryan Tepera, Danny Barnes, and there’s a really good chance that Aaron Loup continues his improbable run with the club, as he’s now the longest tenured member of the team.

Beyond that there is quite a bit of competition for John Gibbons, Pete Walker, and company to sort out. There are young lefties like Matt Dermody and Tim Mayza that’ll push for a job, and Craig Breslow was brought in on a minor league contract. There are also veteran right-handers like Al Alburquerque, John Axford, Jake Petricka, and young Carlos Ramirez, who threw well last year between Triple A and a short stint at the highest level.

More from Jays Journal

• Matt Chapman has been exactly what the Blue Jays needed
• Blue Jays: The goalposts are moving in the right direction
• Single-A Dunedin Blue Jays advance to the Championship Series
• Blue Jays: Comparisons for Alek Manoah’s Second Season
• Blue Jays: Adam Cimber, the unlikely decision King

The debate will also press on about whether or not Joe Biagini should join the bullpen, or if he should go to Buffalo and remain in the starting depth picture. The decision could also be affected by whether or not the front office brings in another reliever, as they’ve said they hope to do. Biagini looked good in his first spring appearance, and even appears to have lost some weight in preparation to handle starting duties a little better, and my guess is he’ll begin the year as a starter in Triple A, at least in April anyway. However, if the former Rule 5 pick does begin the year in Buffalo, the one need that could remain is for a long man.

It’s hard to say if the front office is prioritizing another right-hander, a reliable loogy, or a long man for the bullpen, but we do know it’s an area that they hope to address. Chances are the Jays could put together a decent group from what they have already, but having more depth on the pitching staff is never a bad thing.

Next: Predicting the regular season batting order

What do you think, is there a spring battle I missed talking about? As I’ve said several times, a lot of this could change before Opening Day, but as things currently stand it looks like the battles will be fairly limited during Grapefruit action for the Blue Jays. Hopefully the roster can be firing on all cylinders when the regular season gets underway, and if not, then perhaps there will be a few more competitions for the roster than there are now.