Blue Jays 2015 Year End Awards: Comeback Player

Jays Journal staff nominated several candidates for the 2015 Toronto Blue Jays Comeback Player of the Year!

More from Jays Journal

• Matt Chapman has been exactly what the Blue Jays needed
• Blue Jays: The goalposts are moving in the right direction
• Single-A Dunedin Blue Jays advance to the Championship Series
• Blue Jays: Comparisons for Alek Manoah’s Second Season
• Blue Jays: Adam Cimber, the unlikely decision King

The improvement that the Blue Jays made in 2015 wasn’t just in part to blowing up the trade deadline with the glee of a four-year-old crashing through a block tower. There were notable members of the team that matched the energy brought into the city with the moves to improve their performances and help drive Toronto into the playoffs. It was tough to single out just one member of the Blue Jays who made the biggest leap, and not just for the fans.

Six different players received nods from Jays Journal writers in the voting process. That’s almost 25% of the playoff roster. With so many players garnering enough attention, it’s a sign that there is a lot of credit to spread around for the success the Blue Jays had this year. Conversely, it also means there are a lot of players who could take steps back in 2016. Depends on how the glass is poured. For now, let’s celebrate the steps taken forward and the half glass that’s already been drunk by looking at the players who bounced back and had improved seasons.

Next: Honorable Mention: A Pillar of this Awards Season

Honorable Mention: Kevin Pillar

The strides made by Kevin Pillar this season haven’t gone unnoticed by the Jays Journal staff, as evidenced by J.J. YEAs for Most Improved Player as well as Best Hustle. However, that probably disqualified him from Comeback Player in the eyes of most of the voters. Pillar is a player who is still on the rise, and it will be interesting to see if he can improve on his bat to the point to become a 20/20 threat.

Given recent rumors of discussion between the Blue Jays and Cleveland, it’s possible that Pillar continues to grow by the shores of Lake Erie if the front office brass believes more in the ceiling of Dalton Pompey than the floor Pillar stands on now. If he does leave to acquire pitching help, Pillar has left an impressive highlight reel behind.

Next: Honorable Mention: A Tale of Two Halves

Honorable Mention: R.A. Dickey

More from Jays Journal

• Matt Chapman has been exactly what the Blue Jays needed
• Blue Jays: The goalposts are moving in the right direction
• Single-A Dunedin Blue Jays advance to the Championship Series
• Blue Jays: Comparisons for Alek Manoah’s Second Season
• Blue Jays: Adam Cimber, the unlikely decision King

The former Cy Young award winner was a nominee for this award primarily for the way he bounced back from a horrendous start to the season. The start was so bad it lasted through to the All-Star break. While Josh Donaldson and Jose Bautista headed off to Cincinnati, Dickey was left to mull over an ERA that hovered around 5.00 for most of spring, a 3-10 W-L record and problems with the long ball (17 home runs) and the wild ball (44 walks). It looked like the 40-year-old’s luck had run out and even the $12M option would be far too much for his services.

However, in the second half, Dickey found some of that Mets magic and turned in a sparkling performance over the latter half. 11 of his 15 starts were quality (the 12th falling an inning short), and his knuckler was staying in the strike zone long enough to get swings. He pitched to an 8-1 record, a 2.80 ERA and saw his K/BB ratio rise from an abysmal 1.59 to 3.29 from mid-July on. The Blue Jays will be hoping for similar results to the latter half as they make their run in 2016.

Next: Honorable Mention: The Improbable Comeback

Runner-Up: Marco Estrada

More from Jays Journal

• Matt Chapman has been exactly what the Blue Jays needed
• Blue Jays: The goalposts are moving in the right direction
• Single-A Dunedin Blue Jays advance to the Championship Series
• Blue Jays: Comparisons for Alek Manoah’s Second Season
• Blue Jays: Adam Cimber, the unlikely decision King

Speaking of surviving without David Price, the fact that Estrada resigned to a team-friendly deal makes the fact that Price is on his way out of town a little easier to swallow. Estrada was arguably the best fifth starter in all of baseball, pitching his way from long relief at the start of the season into the Game 1 assignment in the ALCS. The fact that he had the fifth lowest ERA in the American League this season is remarkable considering he led the National League in home runs last season.

The improvements that Estrada made on his change-up and fastball combo already led him to the J.J. YEA for Best Pitcher, and he got recognition from another group as well. Estrada made the Top 10 in voting for the AL Cy Young award. Granted, he was tied with Andrew Miller and Shawn Tolleson, so he wasn’t exactly threatening a late run at the top, but to even garner attention for such an award is a huge boost for Estrada. Now he has to continue to keep batters guessing how fast he is throwing to maintain his new status and justify such an investment.

Next: Runner-Up: The King of the Waiver Wire Claimants

Runner-Up: Chris Colabello

More from Toronto Blue Jays News

• Matt Chapman has been exactly what the Blue Jays needed
• Blue Jays: The goalposts are moving in the right direction
• Single-A Dunedin Blue Jays advance to the Championship Series
• Blue Jays: Comparisons for Alek Manoah’s Second Season
• Blue Jays: Adam Cimber, the unlikely decision King

It is amazing that it took until the ninth J.J. YEA for Colabello to make his first official appearance. The emergence of the former independent league star was a big factor in the sheer potency of the Blue Jays lineup this season. Craig Borden wrote an excellent season review of the man who waited seven years before the Minnesota Twins gave him a chance. After two years with the organization, Toronto claimed him in December and DFA’d the Massachusetts native, expecting him to serve as a cleanup bat in Buffalo.

Colabello did such a good job that he was brought back onto the 40-man roster to replace the ineffective Steve Tolleson. Back in the majors, Colabello continued to smack the ball at a torrid pace. His batting average didn’t drop below .315 the entire season, and his BABIP was an insane .411. That is not a number that is likely to be repeated. If Colabello can have another season of solid contact hitting, hovering around .290, it will be a solid blanket to have behind Jose Bautista and Edwin Encarnacion given their recent drops in average. Either way, Colabello won’t have to worry about making another comeback this spring training.

Next: 2015 Comeback Player: When A Door Doesn't Close, A Window Opens

2015 Comeback Player of the Year: Brett Cecil

At the start of the season, it was known Brett “Goggles” Cecil was going to be in the bullpen. The only question was where? He was the longest-tenured member of the Blue Jays ‘pen, which meant he would have first chance to replace the departed Casey Janssen in the closer role. However, at the end of Spring Training, it was young Miguel Castro who held the baton. It wouldn’t last long, as Castro was sent to Buffalo after a month. By default, Cecil was now the closer.

Toronto Blue Jays

Cecil’s time attempting to nail down games for the Blue Jays was like watching a rookie kayaker get confident paddling through relatively calm waters until hitting the rapids and getting trapped sideways against some rocks. May was a fine month for Cecil, as he only allowed one run in eight innings. The trouble arose in mid-June, during a stretch against the Mets and Orioles. Cecil lost himself, giving up eight runs in three appearances, ballooning his ERA from 3.10 to 5.96. That was enough for John Gibbons, who dropped Cecil from the closer role to hand it to Roberto Osuna.

Perhaps Cecil needed to clear his head from the pressure of being the finisher. After giving up four runs against Baltimore, Cecil did not allow a single earned run for the remainder of the season. 37 times those goggles stared down hitters in the box, and not one of those runners who looked back would cross the plate. Cecil did allow two unearned runs in September, but clearly they weren’t his fault. Cecil finished with a 2.46 ERA in 63 games and his ERA splits speak for themselves. In 18 save situations, Cecil had an ERA of 3.95 and batters were on base at a .305 clip. In 43 other appearances, those numbers drop to 1.99 and .234 respectively, while his strikeout rate doubled. Cecil is not closer material, but he is excellent set-up man material.

Next: Check out Josh Donaldson's J.J. YEA MVP. We Totally Called It!

Cecil’s value was highlighted in the playoffs when Mike Napoli barrel rolled into his calf, knocking him out of the playoffs. Given Aaron Loup‘s family emergency, it would have been nice to have the shutdown lefty in the pen to deal with some of those pesky Royals hitters. The 2015 Comeback Player of the Year award is little consolation, but it should spur Cecil on in 2015 now that he knows what he is, and what he can do to hitters with that knowledge.