The Toronto Blue Jays tendered contracts to seven players on Friday while saying goodbye to Davis Schneider. Ernie Clement, Jose Soriano, Louis Varland, Josh Smith, Nathan Lukes, Spencer Arrighetti and Bowden Francis were all tendered contracts for 2027, at a combined projected $27 million.
But being tendered and actually making it on the Opening Day roster are two different things. By the time the Blue Jays open the 2027 season (whenever that may be), that group of seven could easily be four or five. One of them can't pitch until much later in the summer. One of them is likely headed to Triple-A. And one of the two infielders could be the most affected by a free-agent splash.
Let's start with the locks. Soriano will be in this rotation, barring a spring training injury. The Blue Jays acquired him from the Angels at the deadline for Arjun Nimmala, and he is pencilled into the 2027 rotation alongside Dylan Cease and Trey Yesavage. Tendering him at a projected $5.6 million was never in doubt.
Varland is the other lock. The American League Reliever of the Year posted a 1.27 ERA and 35 saves in his first season as a full-time closer. He is projected to earn $3.8 million and he'll be in the back of the bullpen for 2027. Write both in ink.
The other easy one to project is Francis. His projected contract is $1.3 million, but after undergoing Tommy John surgery in February, he is not expected to return until the middle of next season at the earliest. The Blue Jays are betting that he can turn back into the pitcher who finished 2024 with a 1.33 ERA and a 49-to-6 strikeout-to-walk ratio over his final eight starts.
Spencer Arrighetti, Ernie Clement, Josh Smith and Nathanl Lukes could be on the bubble of the Blue Jays' Opening Day roster
Arrighetti is projected to make $1.9 million as rotation depth, but he is likely destined to begin the year in Triple-A. Carrying a pitcher on that kind of salary in the minors isn't the best piece of business, but Arrighetti needs some work. He posted a 6.35 ERA and 6.85 FIP in 22.2 innings after he joined the Blue Jays.
The club is looking to upgrade the rotation, and if they accomplish that it is hard to see a path to the Opening Day roster for Arrighetti. At worst, he is the Buffalo shuttle option who gets the call when injuries hit.
There are also three hitters who are running out of runway. Clement, Smith and Lukes could see their roles reduced if the Blue Jays upgrade the roster. They could also be used as trade chips and rumours are heating up that the Blue Jays are fielding phone calls about a couple of these guys.
Clement is projected to make $7.6 million in 2027 and clearly the club sees him as an asset they refused to lose for nothing. He is out of minor-league options, and he is coming off a second half that undid his all-star first half. General manager Ross Atkins has already admitted Clement would probably have to earn a regular role in 2027, and that would be much less regular if they sign Brandon Lowe or Jazz Chisholm Jr.
Smith is in a similar spot. Sportsnet's Ben Nicholson-Smith reported that Smith played well enough to work his way into Toronto's plans in 2027. But his path to meaningful playing time will also take a hit if either of those second baseman are picked up. Though Smith can also get reps in, in the outfield which may give him a leg up over Clement.
Speaking of the outfield that's another area the Blue Jays are looking to upgrade. They have their eyes on Seiya Suzuki and Teruaki Sato. One (or both) would eat into playing time for
Lukes, who is projected to earn $2.1 million. The fact that he hits left-handed, like Addison Barger and Brett Bateman, almost, unfortunately, makes him redundant on this roster.
A $2.1 million bench player with Lukes' skill set is absolutely fine to have. But the Blue Jays might be able to flip him into a piece that's going to lessen that redundancy and make them more dynamic across the board.
The Blue Jays have just over a week remaining before they can't make any more moves so if they don't feel like any of these guys are going to be Blue Jays over the long haul, they should just rip off the bandaid now and get it over with.
