Jays Notes: Jays Budget Woes, Jose Bautista, Frank Francisco, and Other Notes

The Jays have been all over the news in the past few weeks and for good reason. Alex Anthopoulos is making so many significant moves, and playing a waiting game with Jose Bautista and Jason Frasor in the arbitration process, that fans across MLB have been forced to look at what’s going on in Toronto these days. One of the things that has become a prominent subject of conversations is whether the Jays are simply in the midst of a massive – and team wide – salary dump, or whether they are simply positioning themselves to be big spenders in 2012 and beyond. With that in mind, here are a few notes that deal with the Jays and Jose Bautista:

  • Matt Binder of The Hardball Times provides us with an excellent piece on spending across MLB in the past decade. You’ll notice that fans do have plenty to chirp about when it comes to the Jays spending in recent times, as they have been above the MLB average and above or at the American League average only three times over the last 10 years. Those years were in 2001, 2002, and 2008 when the Jays finished with 77-81, 78-84, and 86-76 records respectively. The Jays also spent 0.899 (or .101 below the league average) over that span, good enough for 4th place in the AL East and 18th overall. He sums it up with a predictable statistic that has the top 2 spenders in each division making the playoffs 49 times over the last decade, while the bottom 2 spenders in each division have only made the playoffs 16 times. Talk about a direct link between spending and winning!
  • With the piece from Matt Binder in mind, some Jays fans are really getting frustrated at the cost cutting measures Alex Anthopoulos has made recently. The Jays were so close to the playoffs in 2010 that some believed they were “1-2 players away” from making a big move up the rankings in the AL East. I can’t really argue with that, but I will say that to sustain such a drive would be unrealistic without having the means to control costs and salaries over a medium-to-long term. Sure, the Jays could get lucky and make the playoffs once with the group they have in place plus one or two players, but for more than that? I’m not so sure that it would be realistic without clearing enough salary to keep – or acquire – the players the Jays need to sustain a winning and dominant period in their history.
  • The starting point for Jays spending should be Jose Bautista. He was apparently sought after in winter meetings by the Red Sox, so it tells you something about how “positive” teams are that he’ll be able to continue his power numbers in the future. If the Jays do decide to back of of long-term negotiations with Jose, expect more teams like the Red Sox and others to come knocking for his services. Bautista’s agent, Bean Stringfellow, has been getting more vocal about not being approached about a long term deal by Alex Anthopoulos. Meanwhile, Alex has been reluctant to answer any questions about the possibility of such a deal with Jose. I’m not sure if this is positioning by both sides who most likely don’t really want to go through the arbitration process, but a deal could happen quickly if both sides agree to sit and hammer out a longer term deal. There’s still time for this to take place, and nobody needs to panic just yet!
  • Want to become a bigger fan of Frank Francisco than most already are? Look at the 3-year accumulated stats shown herein the Baseball America review of the Francisco for Mike Napoli trade. His stats over the last 3 years make him a very interesting reliever for the Jays if he continues this trend: 11-12 / 3.54 ERA / 165.1 IP / 136 hits / 59 BB / 200 Ks / 1.18 Whip and 32 saves.
  • Alex Anthopoulos is apparently very happy with having a deeper pen for the 2011 season, something that brought a ton of success to San Diego in 2010 and is sought after by most clubs. he got the pieces he was after, and now it’s up to John Farrell and Pat Hentgen to figure out how to get the most out of them. There are rumors the Jays could use 8 relievers instead of the usual 7 on occasion, but that would leave them with only 3 bench options – Jose Molina, John McDonald, and one other player. That player better be pretty special, because he’d be tasked with backing up all 3 outfield positions, first base, and third base. Brett Lawrie anyone?
  • On a minor league note, the Jays re-signedOF Jason Lanewho will inevitably man one of the OF positions in AAA Las Vegas in 2011. They also signed C Tim Mahler, a 6’3 190 lbs Orlando native (son of MLB pitcher Rick Mahler) who was a non-drafted free agent and played for Mid-America Christian University in Oklahoma in 2010, as well as 21 year old OF Joey Hage who is 6’0″ 180 lbs and was last with the St-Louis organization in 2009 (in the GCL and APP leagues). While I don’t have any stats to share for Hage in 2010, Mahler did have the following stats in 2010: 43 games played / 150 ABs / 50 hits / .333 avg / .433 SLG / 10 doubles / 1 triple / 1 HR / 25 RBI / 9 BB / 26 Ks. Other things I could find for Jays fans about Mahler include this article about a key double from him, as well as this profile from Perfect Game USA where they give him a 1.89 sec pop time, excellent arm, and poise when handling the pitching staff. They give him a PG rating of 8, which indicates that they see him as a potential mid-round pick and definite division I prospect. They add that “he is an advanced defensive catcher with upside at the plate.” He’s an interesting signing and it will be interesting to see where he begins his pro career.

That’s all I have for everyone as we wait to see what’s next to come out of the bag of tricks held by Alex Anthopoulos!

- MG 

Like what you read and want to stay informed on all updates here at Jays Journal? Follow Jared and I on Twitter (@JaysJournal and @bigja12) or “Like” our Facebook page

Next Blue Jays Game View full schedule »
Tuesday, Sep 22 Sep7:10at Tampa Bay RaysBuy Tickets

Tags: Frank Francisco Jason Lane Joey Hage Jose Bautista Tim Mahler

  • Robert

    Why is everyone wanting to lock up Bautista long term. He has had ONE good year. Lets see what he does this year. The Jays aren’t going to get him cheap, so lets see if he comes back down to earth, rather then tying $10-15 million on somebody with no track record of hitting more than 16 major league homeruns in a year. He had a career season at the age of 30. A big contract could be an albatross for many years to come. Caution by A.A. is the right response!

    • Mat Germain

      Thanks for the comment Robert, and I definitely understand the hesitation Jays fans have about an extension with Jose after seeing the Wells and Rios deals push the Jays into a corner. However, I believe it’s better to lock him up before he proves he is worth it for a couple of reasons:

      1 – If he does it again, he may price himself out of the Jays range or cost a lot more;
      2 – An extension with Jose would likely be over 3-4 years, not more than that, so it’s not really that big a risk overall, bith in length and in total salary;
      3 – He broke the all-time HR record for the Jays and hit more Hrs than anyone else in MLB….when was the last time a Jays player did that? Never;
      3 – Since he’s become a known commodity, he’s the most marketable player currently on the Jays roster and sells tickets;
      4 – Other teams had all of 2010 to figure his “holes” out but couldn’t. The Red Sox even tried to trade for him because they also think he’ll continue to bash. that’s enough for me to believe that he could easily hit 40+ HRs in 2011 and 2012. How much does a 40 HR hitter cost on the open market? $10-$30 million per season depending on if it’s Adam Dunn or Albert Pujols. So, agreeing to terms with a player like Bautista at the low end of that spectrum makes perfect sense;
      5 – If they don’t sign him to an extension during the pre-season, the jays could lose all leverage and be stuck with nothing more than picks in return for Jose (if he’s rated as a Type A or B FA), and that would be a crying shame; and
      6 – With Vernon Wells now gone, and his role as a leader established as he was charged with leadership roles such as helping Yunel Escobar get acclimatized in 2010, Jose is now one of the few leaders on the squad. The Jays need him in that role over the next few years, even if he doesn’t repeat the 54 HR output.

      That’s just my take on it Robert. If they want to sign him to an extension and trade him if they fall out of the race, I’m on board with that. But to let him walk in 2011 because he wants to test FA, or to let him become even pricier because he proved himself in 2011 just doesn’t seem to make much sense to me at all.

  • Pingback: Jays Minors Transactions Review: July ’10 to Feb ’11 « Jays Journal | A Toronto Blue Jays Blog