Jul 10, 2013; Cleveland, OH, USA; Toronto Blue Jays manager John Gibbons (5) motions to the bullpen in the eighth inning against the Cleveland Indians at Progressive Field. Mandatory Credit: David Richard-USA TODAY Sports

Toronto Blue Jays are running out of options

With the start of spring training the Toronto Blue Jays are looking to fill many holes in their roster. The bench needs to be figured out, the fifth rotation spot and the entire bullpen. We are all too familiar with the injuries that occurred to the Blue Jays last season, but injuries have more than one problem.

I was once told that a problem is a misunderstood opportunity, (thanks to my ninth grade teacher). So lets look at this “opportunity.”

First of all, when a player gets injured you have to replace the injured player, and most often the replacement is from the minors. When a player is brought up to the major league team and then sent back down for at least 20 days, you use an option on that player’s contract. Once all the options are exhausted, that player must clear waivers before being sent down again, exposing him to other teams to take. This season the Blue Jays have eight players out of options going into Spring Training this year.

Of course seven of the eight players are pitchers (due to the many injuries experienced by the pitching staff last season.) The players that are out of options this year are: Right-handed pitchers Dustin McGowan, Esmil Rogers, Todd Redmond, Sergio Santos and Jeremy Jeffress, lefties Brett Cecil and Luis Perez, and outfielder Moises Sierra.

The Jays like all these players and does not want to lose them to other teams for nothing. The only question remains is how does this affect the roster?

I believe that the Jays will head north with a short bench and an eight man bullpen to accommodate this problem-sorry opportunity. The Jays refuse to give up on McGowan, so exposing him to waivers makes no sense. Lucas Silva wrote earlier that he thinks McGowan, Redmond and Rogers are front-runners to the fifth spot in the rotation. I believe he is right. Also discussed by Lucas, what happened to Ricky Romero last spring may happen to J.A. Happ this spring. If Happ can’t get outs early in the count and elevate his pitch count (like he has does throughout his career) he may be starting the season in Buffalo. Redmond deserves to be the fifth start from what he did last year. He will be more productive in the rotation then in the pen, so Toronto will have two long relievers in McGowan and Rogers.

Santos and Cecil should be locks while Jeffress and Perez will also have an opportunity to land a spot in the bullpen. Add in McGowan and Rogers that’s already seven players. Now you can’t forget closer Casey Janssen and all-star Steve Delabar or left-hander Aaron Loup who was used a lot by manager John Gibbons last season, we have ten players for eight spots. Personally I think the odd men out are Perez and Jeffress, but luckily I don’t have to make that decision. And I haven’t even mentioned Neil Wagner yet, who may find himself in Buffalo simply because he still does have options.

As for Sierra, I wrote a bit earlier that he will win the fourth outfield spot for the bench as it stands right now.

The final spot in the rotation and the bullpen is a mess as it stands right now. This piece just suggested that Kyle Drabek, Drew Hutchison or Chad Jenkins don’t even have considerations to become the fifth starter, which is not true. I’m rather glad not to be the one who has to make the final decision. After all I was the guy who said Josh Johnson will win the Cy Young Award last season, so what do I know?

Next Blue Jays Game View full schedule »
Friday, Aug 2929 Aug7:07New York YankeesBuy Tickets

Tags: Toronto Blue Jays

  • David Stewart

    I like your honesty. I thought Josh Johnson would be a good man to keep. I think that was probably a bad decision. According to Wilmer he will be a dude in San Diego. I should not have bought my crystal ball on EBay.

    • Jason Ramnauth

      I also believe JJ will have a big season this season, there is no way I can be wrong back to back years. My crystal ball is from Wal-mart

  • brad

    ugh…. I think the 8 man bullpen is the worst. 4 bench spots where 1 is a backup catcher? Need a backup infielder as well(and let’s face it that is a useless bat on this team). You then probably have Sierra to platoon at DH/backup the outfield and need another outfielder for when Sierra is DH(lest someone get hurt and you need to make the pitcher hit). That leaves exactly 0 good pinch hit options(especially against lefty starters where Sierra starts)…. ughhh

    • Jason Ramnauth

      well I know he played first base in winter ball, so that might solve some problems for Lind and EE at first and DH. I understand your concern but I expect a big year from the Jays.

  • malna

    “When a player is brought up to the major league team, you use an option on that players contract.”


    The opposite is true.

    When a player is sent down to the minor leagues, a minor league option is used. That option can be used at any given point during the calendar year/season in which it was initially exercised.

    Kevin Pillar, for example, still has all 3 minor league options remaining as his minor league contract was purchased in mid-August, and he was not sent down to the MiLB for the rest of the year.

    The rest of this article is also just weird….

    • http://jaysjournal.com/ Michael Wray

      Thanks malna should have caught that article has been updated.

  • Pingback: Toronto Blue Jays are running out of options – Jays Journal – A … | Betting Baseball Club

  • Pingback: Pros and Cons for Toronto carrying an eight man bullpen - Jays Journal - A Toronto Blue Jays Fan Site - News, Blogs, Opinion and More